To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
This chapter will first discuss some theoretical aspects of terrorism in Swat society with special reference to structural functionalism or functionalist theories that created a space for the rise of Taliban, because it explores a set of human behaviour and complexities of a society to maintain harmony and peace (Ritzer, 2010). Second, it will discuss the conceptualisation of women and education in armed conflicts. The chapter then ends with some reflections about the suitability of feminists’ peace and conflict theories in Swat context.
According to the theory, every society has its stable social structure. This social structure has its own harmonious way of functioning that is acceptable and recognised for a society. However, as time passes, changes occur in a society's setup, and people try to change or modify their old-fashioned functions. Thus, societies accept or reject new social functions based on their suitability or unsuitability within their cultural and societal norms. However, if the new functions are disapproved by a group, known as ‘dysfunctional group’, or the concept of ‘dysfunction’, whereas functions contribute to the adjustment of the system, dysfunctions are those consequences that lead to instability and ultimately change (Elwell, 2013: 1). The change bearer group in the social structure continues their struggle within society. This tussle always creates clashes and conflicts within a society when the functions of social structure are unacceptable for the changing group, and the existing functions holder rejects the new social structure changes. This tug of war between the societal structural functional and dysfunctional forces (groups) is a continuous process throughout human history. However, Merton asserts that institutional structures and cultural elements are interrelated and mutually supporting and that the dominant orientation of socio-cultural systems is stability (Elwell, 2013: 1).
As we survey the course of history, it seems reasonably clear that all major social structures have in due course been cumulatively modified or abruptly terminated. In either event, they have not been eternally fixed and unyielding to change. (Merton 1948/1968, 95, cited in Elwell, 2013)
Restructuring an existing society with social mechanisms adjusts the new acceptable social functions with existing social norms; otherwise, the society repulses it.
In this chapter, I discuss the stories of courageous women who have struggled for education, peace and prosperity in Swat Valley. In addition, I analyse the Swat women's unending hope and efforts for peacekeeping and peacebuilding, where education for all and everyone gained momentum nowadays.
Pakistan is one of the world's most populous countries where the struggle for socio-economic development, education and the redefinition of religion and cultural discourses are challenging dynamics. It has the least gender equitable measures among South Asian countries. There are many challenges for women in the country, but the vanguard one is targeting and attacking education and women to deprive them of their fundamental rights of education, work and to make personal decisions about their life.
The analysis in the second story about the educated women of Swat highlights the most disastrous time of their life, gender issues and the unequal power relation of gender in conflicts they went through. Their life stories give us their diverse life experiences of torture, fear and oppression yet with hope, optimism and peace too. They demonstrated their experiences during three phases: terrorism, counter-insurgency destructions and their forced displacement that all considered more gendered episodes.
As mentioned, the tragic story of Swat commenced with unjust social and legislature of the prevailing law that exploited their fundamental rights since the merger (1969) (Sultan-i-Rome, 2008). These circumstances were well prepared ground for TNSM, which was a peaceful restoration of Sharia law by Sufi Muhammad against the corrupt and inefficient judicial system (Hussain, 2001) that later became the root cause of the rise of militancy (Majeed 2016 and Rome, 2008). Thus, the discourse constructed by Fazlullah was based on Wahabism, revolving around jihad, extremism, anti-modernism, anti-state and anti-women (Hussain et al., 2011; cited in Majeed, 2016: 97). To suppress the Taliban's conservative barbaric ideology, which I am not calling Islam because it has nothing to do with the peaceful philosophy of Islam, they reached their extreme form of violence and aggression for political empowerment.
For centuries, in Pukhtun society, lack of education deprived women of their socio-political and economic participation which is considered the main impediment to their empowerment (Naz and Chaudhry, 2011).
This study concluded the ways in which women are excluded from education and from holding positions of power because of male domination across the globe. Therefore, women have limited access to public authority over their private lives. Furthermore, each theory of feminism discussed here has played a crucial role in the twenty-first century of feminist theorisation and politics, and together they constitute a source of inspiration for the future. I have described the basic exchange between feminism and Western philosophy that runs through these feminisms and their relationship. Where feminism will go from here is unclear, but the point is that feminism, by any name, is alive in academia and outside of it. Some older feminists feel discouraged by the younger generations’ seeming ignorance of or disregard for the struggles and achievements of the early movement. They see little progress (the pay gap has not significantly narrowed in 60 years) and are fearful that the new high-heeled, red-lipped college girls are letting go of hard-won gains. This, however, is not likely the case. There have always been feminisms in movements, not just one ideology, and there have always been tensions, points and counterpoints. The political, social and intellectual feminist movements have always been chaotic, multivalent and disconcerting, and let's hope they continue to be so; it's a sign that they are thriving. I concluded that economic classes, language of instructions and parental education patterns were the reinforcing elements for the women of Pukhtunkhwa to access higher education. The upper and upper-middle-class women were confident of continuing higher education if they wanted to. Women of Pukhtunkhwa preferred marriage over higher education. Career was not their priority or was the second option and even then only in the fields of medicine and teaching. If a choice between a career and higher education was available to them, they would choose higher education. It was surprising that the women in contemporary Pukhtunkhwa were happy to give all the decision-making power to their family men because a lack of training made them hesitant to decide their future. However, on the other hand, they do demand women-only educational institutions throughout Pukhtunkhwa.
In this chapter, I will further elaborate on my key findings in the following conceptual areas: synthesising feminist theories in higher education in Pukhtunkhwa, the inappropriateness of applying Western models to a non-Western setting, redefining cultural and religious discourses, lack of female role models in Pukhtunkhwa society, women's lack of training and experience in the decision-making process, money, marriage and masters and the appli-cation and relevance of Marxist feminism and Islamic socialism.
Synthesising Feminist Theories in Higher Education in Pukhtunkhwa
The theoretical framework of this study has been informed by work on gender inequality in education from different feminist theories (liberal, radical, Marxist and Islamic), with a common underlying theme being challenging the male-dominated nature of the field of education (Mattu and Hussain, 2004; Dean, 2007). My study adopted a radical Islamic feminist approach by challenging the cultural and patriarchal Pukhtunkhwa traditional society to empower women. As I made clear in the section addressing Marxist feminism, this study also adopted some aspects of a Marxist feminist approach, especially the recognition that women's experiences in Pukhtunkhwa (as elsewhere) are influenced by capitalism and its attendant hierarchical set of social class relations as well as by patriarchy.
I am seeking empowerment for women in Pukhtunkhwa to make decisions about their lives without confrontation with their religion and the men of their families. Instead, they should be free to achieve their goals and realise their rights in partnership with men and with an understanding of Islamic theology (Contractor, 2010) set out by contemporary writers and the concept of Ijtihad, which enables them to challenge patriarchal interpretations of their Islamic faith. In the analysis of my interview data, my sample women seemed very accepting and passive regarding their own experiences and situations. This study opens an arena for the Pukhtun women to have more confidence in making their voices heard which might contribute to transformation.
Furthermore, my study rejected the argument put forward by liberal feminists that equality should be brought about by state law. Pakistan already has a constitutional law to provide equal opportunities for men and women in edu-cation and other fields of life, but this exists only in official documents, not in practice. Similarly, the country's name is the ‘Islamic Republic of Pakistan’: it is an Islamic country, but Islam is not truly implemented in state affairs and law.
Ethnography and feminist methodologies and methods have become central in these studies. I acknowledge my personal areas of concern and interest as a researcher. I cannot isolate myself from these studies. I presented myself as a liberal-nationalist feminist, who grew up in an educated family in Pukhtunkhwa, as a daughter who went to school and completed her higher education with the support of her feminist-nationalist Baba (father), who encouraged her to escape the traditional roles of Pukhtun women. My Baba's extreme love and belief in me made me a woman of audacity and nerve. Thus, my research is based on my own life experiences that led me towards gender issues and social justice for Pukhtun women. It is interesting that as an author I share common goals and some common experiences to give voice to the unvoiced, and I positioned myself as an ‘in-between’ researcher:
meaning while we, the ‘in-between’ researchers, are originally women from a South Asian country with a Muslim majority, we have spent a considerable part of our lives in the West. While studying and living in the West has undoubtedly influenced our lives and perceptions, we still do not see ourselves as Western. This is a matter of conscious political choice as well because of the politics of the day which constantly remind us that we are not Western, such as the racial profiling at certain airports these days. (Pourzand, 2003: 23)
I further explained the in-between researcher position in this chapter to familiarise my readers with the use of this term in research. However, here I discuss how my story has a place in this book – who I am and where I am coming from – and how it has had a deep impact on the selection and development of my research questions, contexts and participants in both studies. As a researcher, I am well-placed to conduct these studies because of my own personal background, nationality, family heritage and gender. As I men-tioned, I grew up in this area, went to school and completed my MA degree at the University of Peshawar.
Drawing on students' experiences of structural racism in the UK higher education institutions, this book offers an informed analysis on the barriers to Black student progression. It documents success stories and provides key recommendations for the sector on how to eliminate discrimination and achieve positive results for Black students.
This book explores a wide diversity of approaches to help understand the policy movement phenomena, providing a useful guide on global studies in education, as well as insights into the future of this dynamic area of work.
This book combines assemblage theory and policy mobilities to inform the study of comparative and international education (CIE), focusing on education policy and how such policy moves are enacted.
School leaders work in increasingly complex systems. Alongside leading learning, they daily navigate the needs and expectations of educational departments, teachers, students, parents, society, and themselves. Leadership can therefore be a dynamic vocational calling, but studies show that principals' professional agency, career sustainability, and wellbeing are diminishing. This Element brings a fresh perspective to how educational leaders can be better served and supported by collaborative, co-agentic partnerships at this time. It makes the case for professional supervision, a practice commonplace in clinical and pastoral professions that offers facilitated, action-oriented attention to the interplay of role, 'soul', and context. As a practice-based primer, this Element reclaims supervision against outdated associations with performance management by drawing on interdisciplinary research and the authors' own experience as supervisor partners with principals. It proposes a new schema of professional supervision in education informed by curiosity, unlearning, resonance, and attunement in a rapidly changing world.
This article addresses a critical gap in international research concerning digital literacies and empowerment among adults who are English as an additional language (EAL) learners. In the Australian context, where digital communication and services are embedded in all aspects of life and work, proficiency in digital literacies, including advanced technologies like generative artificial intelligence (AI), is vital for working and living in Australia. Despite the increasing prevalence and significance of generative AI platforms such as ChatGPT, there is a notable absence of dedicated programs to assist EAL learners in understanding and utilising generative AI, potentially impacting their employability and everyday life. This article presents findings from a larger study conducted within training providers, spanning adult educational institutions nationwide. Through analysis of data gathered from surveys and focus groups, the article investigates the knowledge and attitudes of students, educators, and leaders regarding integrating generative AI into the learning program for adult EAL learners. The results reveal a hesitance among educators, particularly concerning beginning language learners, in incorporating generative AI into educational programs. Conversely, many adult learners demonstrate enthusiasm for learning about its potential benefits despite having limited understanding. These disparities underscore the pressing need for comprehensive professional development for educators and program leaders. The findings also highlight the need to develop the AI literacy of learners to foster their understanding and digital empowerment. The article concludes by advocating for a systemic approach to include generative AI as an important part of learning programs with students often from adult migrant and refugee backgrounds.
Drawing upon Darvin and Norton’s (2015) model of investment, this article examines how Xing and Jimmy (both pseudonyms) as two male Chinese English as a foreign language learners from rural migrant backgrounds negotiate their identities and assemble their social and cultural resources to invest in autonomous digital literacies for language learning and the assertion of a legitimate place in urban spaces. Employing a connective ethnographic design, this study collected data through interviews, reflexive journals, digital artifacts, and on-campus observations. Data were analyzed using an inductive thematic approach as well as within- and cross-case data analysis methods. The findings indicate that Xing and Jimmy experienced a profound sense of alienation and exclusion as they migrated from under-resourced rural spaces to the urban elite field. The unequal power relations in urban classrooms subjected them to marginalized and inadequate rural identities by denying them the right to speak and be heard. However, engaging with digital literacies in the wild allowed these migrant learners to access a wide range of linguistic, cultural, and symbolic resources, empowering them to reframe their identities as legitimate English speakers. The acquisition of such legitimacy enabled them to challenge the prevailing rural–urban exclusionary ideologies to claim the right to speak. This article closes by offering implications for empowering rural migrant students as socially competent members of the Chinese higher education system in the digital age.
This three-year longitudinal case study explored how trilingual Uyghur intranational migrant students utilized digital technologies to learn languages and negotiate their identities in Han-dominant environments during their internal migrations within China, a topic that has been scarcely researched before. Adopting a poststructuralist perspective of identity, the study traced four Uyghur students who migrated from underdeveloped southern Xinjiang to northern Xinjiang for junior high school education, and to more developed cities in eastern and southern China for senior high school education and higher education. A qualitative approach was adopted, utilizing semi-structured interviews, class and campus observations, daily conversations, WeChat conversations, participants’ reflections, and assignments. Findings reveal that Uyghur minority students utilized digital technologies to bridge the English proficiency gap with Han students, negotiate their marginalized identities, integrate into the mainstream education system, and extend the empowerment to other ethnic minority students. This was in sharp contrast to the significant challenges and identity crises they faced when they did not have access to digital technologies to learn Mandarin in boarding secondary schools. An unprecedented finding is that, with digital empowerment, Uyghur minority students could achieve accomplishments that were even difficult for Han students to attain and gain upward social mobility by finding employment in Han-dominant first-tier cities. The implications of utilizing digital technologies to support intranational migrant ethnic minority students’ language learning and identity development are discussed.
Combining critical race and indigenous theories, this collection explores critical racial literacy and anti-racist praxis in Australia's education system. Demystifying 'critical anti-racism praxis,' it advocates for multidisciplinary approaches, offering actionable ideas from educators across a range of disciplines.