For graphs
G and
H, the Ramsey number
r(G,H) is the smallest positive integer
N such that any red/blue edge colouring of the complete graph
K_N contains either a red
G or a blue
H. A book
B_n is a graph consisting of
n triangles all sharing a common edge.
Recently, Conlon, Fox, and Wigderson conjectured that for any
0\lt \alpha \lt 1, the random lower bound
r(B_{\lceil \alpha n\rceil },B_n)\ge (\sqrt{\alpha }+1)^2n+o(n) is not tight. In other words, there exists some constant
\beta \gt (\sqrt{\alpha }+1)^2 such that
r(B_{\lceil \alpha n\rceil },B_n)\ge \beta n for all sufficiently large
n. This conjecture holds for every
\alpha \lt 1/6 by a result of Nikiforov and Rousseau from 2005, which says that in this range
r(B_{\lceil \alpha n\rceil },B_n)=2n+3 for all sufficiently large
n.
We disprove the conjecture of Conlon, Fox, and Wigderson. Indeed, we show that the random lower bound is asymptotically tight for every
1/4\leq \alpha \leq 1. Moreover, we show that for any
1/6\leq \alpha \le 1/4 and large
n,
r(B_{\lceil \alpha n\rceil }, B_n)\le \left (\frac 32+3\alpha \right ) n+o(n), where the inequality is asymptotically tight when
\alpha =1/6 or
1/4. We also give a lower bound of
r(B_{\lceil \alpha n\rceil }, B_n) for
1/6\le \alpha \lt \frac{52-16\sqrt{3}}{121}\approx 0.2007, showing that the random lower bound is not tight, i.e., the conjecture of Conlon, Fox, and Wigderson holds in this interval.