The inhabitants of comets as depicted in the Plurality des Mondes of Fontenelle– Ideas of Lambert respecting the habitability of comets–That comets are the abode of human beings is a hypothesis incompatible with the received facts of astronomy.
After Newton, and especially in the eighteenth century, by a not unnatural reaction of ideas from the Aristotelian doctrine of transient meteors, comets were regarded as bodies, stable and permanent as the planets ; they were obedient to the same laws of movement, and differed only as regards appearance, by their nebulosities and tails. The astronomers of that time, taken up with the verification and calculation of their positions and orbits, occupied themselves little or not at all with the study of details which were purely physical, such as are now called cometary phenomena. Regarding them as spheroids, solid like the planets, and similar to them in the constituents of their nuclei, to people them with inhabitants followed in the natural sequence of ideas.
Fontenelle, who, as we know, was a believer in the theory of vortices, and who, moreover, regarded the heads and tails of comets as simple optical appearances, thus expresses himself in the Pluralité des Mondes.
‘ Comets,’ he observes, ‘ are planets which belong to a neighbouring vortex ; they move near the boundaries of it ; but this vortex, being unequally pressed upon by those that are adjacent to it, is rounder above and flatter below, and it is the part below that concerns us.