While prior studies have analyzed Skin Picking Disorder as a unitary condition, little research has been done examining clinical and neurocognitive characteristics of specific subtypes. The objective of this study is to analyze differences in impulsivity, emotional regulation, symptom severity, cognitive performance, and the presence of comorbid psychiatric conditions between focused and automatic subtypes of Skin Picking Disorder.

83 adults aged 18–65 with skin picking disorder were enrolled at the University of Chicago and separated into 4 skin picking subtype groups based on high or low levels of focused and automatic picking scores on the Milwaukee Inventory for the Dimension of Adult Skin Picking. The 4 subtype groups were separated using K-means clustering. Each group completed the same clinical and neurocognitive assessments. ANOVA or Chi-Squared tests were used to analyze differences in assessment outcomes.

Higher focused picking scores were significantly associated with greater symptom severity and impairment. Differences in levels of automatic/focused picking were not associated with impulsivity, emotional/behavior regulations, or neurocognitive outcomes.

The findings suggest that focused skin pickers are likely to have more impairment due to their behavior compared to automatic or mixed pickers; however, overall, the groups did not differ in clinical or neurocognitive measures. Thus, it is unclear whether focused and automatic picking are particularly useful clinically in subtyping skin picking disorder.