Hostname: page-component-65f69f4695-22rqw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-06-28T10:45:41.922Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Sustainability Preferences Under Stress: Evidence from COVID-19

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 November 2022

Robin Döttling  and
Sehoon Kim
Robin Döttling
Affiliation:
Erasmus University Rotterdam Rotterdam School of Management doettling@rsm.nl
Sehoon Kim*
Affiliation:
University of Florida Warrington College of Business
*
sehoon.kim@warrington.ufl.edu (corresponding author)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

We document fragile demand for socially responsible investments (SRIs) by retail mutual fund investors. Using COVID-19 as an economic shock, we show funds with higher sustainability ratings experienced sharper declines in retail flows during the pandemic, controlling for fund characteristics. The decline in retail SRI fund flows is sharper than that of institutional flows, more pronounced when economies are hit harder by COVID-19, and unlikely to be driven by fund performance, past flows and size, or shifting investor attention. Corroborated by out-of-sample survey evidence, our findings highlight the high sensitivity of SRI demand by retail investors with respect to income shocks.

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 59 , Issue 2 , March 2024 , pp. 435 - 473
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington

Footnotes

We thank an anonymous referee, Vikas Agarwal, Rui Alburquerque, Jennifer Conrad (the editor), Gustavo Cortes, Celine Fei, Mark Flannery, Andrei Goncalves, Samuel Hartzmark, Kewei Hou, Joel Houston, Nitish Kumar, Tao Li, Xiaomeng Lu, Christian Lundblad, Pedro Matos, Andy Naranjo, Nimal Nimalendran, Martin Oehmke, Dongyang Pan, Lubos Pastor, David Rakowski, Sugata Ray, Luc Renneboog, Jay Ritter, Jacob Sagi, Zacharias Sautner, Gill Segal, Elena Simintzi, Paul Smeets, Laura Starks, René Stulz, Yuehua Tang, Blair Vorsatz, Alexander Wagner, Baolian Wang, Haibei Zhao, and conference/seminar participants at the 2021 SAIF Sustainable Finance Forum, 2021 European Retail Investment Conference, Fall 2020 Virtual Asset Management Seminar Series, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, University of Florida, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Seoul National University, VU University Amsterdam, and Concordia University for helpful comments and suggestions. This article was previously circulated under the title “Sustainability Preferences Under Stress: Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows During COVID-19.”

References

Albuquerque, R.; Koskinen, Y.; Yang, S.; and Zhang, C.. “Resiliency of Environmental and Social Stocks: An Analysis of the Exogenous COVID-19 Market Crash.” Review of Corporate Finance Studies, 9 (2020), 593–621.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Albuquerque, R.; Koskinen, Y.; and Zhang, C.. “Corporate Social Responsibility and Firm Risk: Theory and Empirical Evidence.” Management Science, 65 (2019), 4451–4469.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alekseev, G.; Amer, S.; Gopal, M.; Kuchler, T.; Schneider, J.; Stroebel, J.; and Wernerfelt, N.. “The Effects of COVID-19 on U.S. Small Businesses: Evidence from Owners, Managers, and Employees.” Management Science, forthcoming (2023).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alfaro, L.; Chari, A.; Greenland, A. N.; and Schott, P. K.. “Aggregate and Firm-Level Stock Returns During Pandemics, in Real Time.” NBER Working Paper No. 26950 (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altig, D.; Baker, S. R.; Barrero, J. M.; Bloom, N.; Bunn, P.; Chen, S.; Davis, S. J.; Leather, J.; Meyer, B. H.; Mihaylov, E.; Mizen, P.; Parker, N. B.; Renault, T.; Smietanka, P.; and Thwaites, G.. “Economic Uncertainty Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Journal of Public Economics, 191 (2020), 1–13.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Baker, S. R.; Bloom, N.; Davis, S. J.; Kost, K. J.; Sammon, M. C.; and Viratyosin, T.. “The Unprecedented Stock Market Reaction to COVID-19.” Review of Asset Pricing Studies, 10 (2020a), 742–758.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baker, S. R.; Farrokhnia, R. A.; Meyer, S.; Pagel, M.; and Yannelis, C.. “How Does Household Spending Respond to an Epidemic? Consumption During the 2020 COVID-19 Pandemic.” Review of Asset Pricing Studies, 10 (2020b), 834–862.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baker, S. R.; Farrokhnia, R. A.; Meyer, S.; Pagel, M.; and Yannelis, C.. “Income, Liquidity, and the Consumption Response to the 2020 Economic Stimulus Payments.” NBER Working Paper No. 27097 (2020c).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baldauf, M.; Garlappi, L.; and Yannelis, C.. “Does Climate Change Affect Real Estate Prices? Only if You Believe in It.” Review of Financial Studies, 33 (2020), 1256–1295.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bansal, R.; Wu, D.; and Yaron, A.. “Socially Responsible Investing in Good and Bad Times.” Review of Financial Studies, 35 (2022), 2067–2099.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barber, B. M., and Odean, T.. “The Internet and the Investor.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15 (2001), 41–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barko, T.; Cremers, M.; and Renneboog, L.. “Shareholder Engagement on Environmental, Social, and Governance Performance.” Journal of Business Ethics, 180 (2021), 777–812.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bauer, R.; Ruof, T.; and Smeets, P.. “Get Real! Individuals Prefer More Sustainable Investments.” Review of Financial Studies, 34 (2021), 3976–4043.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben-Rephael, A.; Kandel, S.; and Wohl, A.. “Measuring Investor Sentiment with Mutual Fund Flows.” Journal of Financial Economics, 104 (2012), 363–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bernstein, A.; Gustafson, M. T.; and Lewis, R.. “Disaster on the Horizon: The Price Effect of Sea Level Rise.” Journal of Financial Economics, 134 (2019), 253–272.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blanchett, D.; Finke, M.; and Reuter, J.. “Portfolio Delegation and 401(k) Plan Participant Responses to COVID-19.” NBER Working Paper No. 27438 (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boehmer, E.; Jones, C. M.; Zhang, X.; and Zhang, X.. “Tracking Retail Investor Activity.” Journal of Finance, 76 (2021), 2249–2305.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bollen, N. P. B. “Mutual Fund Attributes and Investor Behavior.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 42 (2007), 683–708.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bolton, P., and Kacperczyk, M.. “Do Investors Care About Carbon Risk?” Journal of Financial Economics, 142 (2021), 517–549.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cajner, T.; Crane, L. D.; Decker, R. A.; Grigsby, J.; Hamins-Puertolas, A.; Hurst, E.; Kurz, C.; and Yildirmaz, A.. “The U.S. Labor Market During the Beginning of the Pandemic Recession.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Summer (2020a), 3–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cajner, T.; Crane, L. D.; Decker, R. A.; Hamins-Puertolas, A.; and Kurz, C.. “Tracking Labor Market Developments During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Preliminary Assessment.” NBER Working Paper (2020b).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cao, J.; Titman, S.; Zhan, X.; and Zhang, W.. “ESG Preference, Institutional Trading, and Stock Return Patterns.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, forthcoming (2023).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ceccarelli, M.; Ramelli, S.; and Wagner, A. F.. “Low-Carbon Mutual Funds.” ECGI Working Paper (2021).Google Scholar
Cen, X. “Going Mobile, Investor Behavior, and Financial Fragility.” Working Paper (2019).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chinco, A. M.; Hartzmark, S. M.; and Sussman, A. B.. “A New Test of Risk Factor Relevance.” Journal of Finance, 77 (2022), 2183–2238.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coibion, O.; Gorodnichenko, Y.; and Weber, M.. “The Cost of the COVID-19 Crisis: Lockdowns, Macroeconomic Expectations, and Consumer Spending.” NBER Working Paper No. 27141 (2020a).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coibion, O.; Gorodnichenko, Y.; and Weber, M.. “Labor Markets During the COVID-19 Crisis: A Preliminary View.” BFI Working Paper (2020b).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Croce, M. M.; Farroni, P.; and Wolfskeil, I.. “When the Markets Get CO.V.I.D: Contagion, Viruses, and Information Diffusion.” CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP14674 (2020).Google Scholar
Del Guercio, D., and Tkac, P. A.. “The Effect of Morningstar Ratings on Mutual Fund Flow.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 43 (2008), 907–936.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ding, W.; Levine, R.; Lin, C.; and Xie, W.. “Corporate Immunity to the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Journal of Financial Economics, 141 (2021), 802–830.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dyck, A.; Lins, K. V.; Roth, L.; and Wagner, H. F.. “Do Institutional Investors Drive Corporate Social Responsibility? International Evidence.” Journal of Financial Economics, 131 (2019), 693–714.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engle, R. F.; Giglio, S.; Kelly, B. T.; Lee, H.; and Stroebel, J.. “Hedging Climate Change News.” Review of Financial Studies, 33 (2020), 1184–1216.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, R. B., and Fahlenbrach, R.. “Institutional Investors and Mutual Fund Governance: Evidence from Retail-Institutional Fund Twins.” Review of Financial Studies, 25 (2012), 3530–3571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fahlenbrach, R.; Rageth, K.; and Stulz, R. M.. “How Valuable is Financial Flexibility when Revenue Stops? Evidence from the COVID-19 Crisis.” Review of Financial Studies, 34 (2021), 5474–5521.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E. F., and French, K. R.. “A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model.” Journal of Financial Economics, 116 (2015), 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferriani, F., and Natoli, F.. “ESG Risks in Times of COVID-19.” Applied Economics Letters, 28 (2020), 1537–1541.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forsythe, E.; Kahn, L. B.; Lange, F.; and Wiczer, D. G.. “Labor Demand in the Time of COVID-19: Evidence from Vacancy Postings and UI Claims.” Journal of Public Economics, 189 (2020), 1–7.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Franzoni, F., and Schmalz, M. C.. “Fund Flows and Market States.” Review of Financial Studies, 30 (2017), 2621–2673.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frazzini, A., and Lamont, O. A.. “Dumb Money: Mutual Fund Flows and the Cross-Section of Stock Returns.” Journal of Financial Economics, 88 (2008), 299–322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibson, R.; Glossner, S.; Krueger, P.; Matos, P.; and Steffen, T.. “Do Responsible Investors Invest Responsibly?” Review of Finance, 26 (2022), 1389–1432.Google Scholar
Giglio, S.; Kelly, B. T.; and Stroebel, J.. “Climate Finance.” Annual Review of Financial Economics, 13 (2021), 15–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giglio, S.; Maggiori, M.; Stroebel, J.; and Utkus, S.. “The Joint Dynamics of Investor Beliefs and Trading During the COVID-19 Crash.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118 (2021), 1–9.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Glossner, S.; Matos, P.; Ramelli, S.; and Wagner, A. F.. “Do Institutional Investors Stabilize Equity Markets in Crisis Periods? Evidence from COVID-19.” ECGI Working Paper (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldstein, I.; Kopytov, A.; Shen, L.; and Xiang, H.. “On ESG Investing: Heterogeneous Preferences, Information, and Asset Prices.” Working Paper (2022).Google Scholar
Gormsen, N. J., and Koijen, R. S. J.. “Coronavirus: Impact on Stock Prices and Growth Expectations.” Review of Asset Pricing Studies, 10 (2020), 574–597.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Granja, J.; Makridis, C.; Yannelis, C.; and Zwick, E.. “Did the Paycheck Protection Program Hit the Target?” Journal of Financial Economics, 145 (2022), 725–761.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hartzmark, S. M., and Sussman, A. B.. “Do Investors Value Sustainability? A Natural Experiment Examining Ranking and Fund Flows.” Journal of Finance, 74 (2019), 2789–2837.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoepner, A. G. F.; Oikonomou, I.; Sautner, Z.; Starks, L. T.; and Zhou, X. Y.. “ESG Shareholder Engagement and Downside Risk.” Working Paper (2022).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horvath, A.; Kay, B.; and Wix, C.. “The COVID-19 Shock and Consumer Credit: Evidence from Credit Card Data.” Working Paper (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Humphrey, J.; Kogan, S.; Sagi, J.; and Starks, L. T.. “The Asymmetry in Responsible Investing Preferences.” Working Paper (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ilhan, E.; Krueger, P.; Sautner, Z.; and Starks, L. T.. “Climate Risk Disclosure and Institutional Investors.” Review of Financial Studies, forthcoming (2023).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kacperczyk, M.; Van Nieuwerburgh, S.; and Veldkamp, L.. “Time-varying Fund Manager Skill.” Journal of Finance 69 (2014), 1455–1484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalda, A.; Loos, B.; Previtero, A.; and Hackethal, A.. “Smart(phone) Investing? A Within Investor-Time Analysis of New Technologies and Trading Behavior.” Working Paper (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koijen, R. S. J., and Yogo, M.. “A Demand System Approach to Asset Pricing.” Journal of Political Economy, 127 (2019), 1475–1515.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Krueger, P.; Sautner, Z.; and Starks, L. T.. “The Importance of Climate Risks for Institutional Investors.” Review of Financial Studies, 33 (2020), 1067–1111.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lins, K. V.; Servaes, H.; and Tamayo, A.. “Social Capital, Trust, and Firm Performance: The Value of Corporate Social Responsibility During the Financial Crisis.” Journal of Finance, 72 (2017), 1785–1824.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oehmke, M., and Opp, M.. “A Theory of Socially Responsible Investment.” Working Paper (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ozik, G.; Sadka, R.; and Shen, S.. “Flattening the Illiquidity Curve: Retail Trading During the COVID-19 Lockdown.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 56 (2021), 2356–2388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pastor, L.; Stambaugh, R. F.; and Taylor, L. A.. “Dissecting Green Returns.” Journal of Financial Economics, 146 (2022), 403–424.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pastor, L.; Stambaugh, R. F.; and Taylor, L. A.. “Sustainable Investing in Equilibrium.” Journal of Financial Economics, 142 (2021b), 550–571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pastor, L., and Vorsatz, B.. “Mutual Fund Performance and Flows During the COVID-19 Crisis.” Review of Asset Pricing Studies, 10 (2020), 791–833.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pedersen, L. H.; Fitzgibbons, S.; and Pomorski, L.. “Responsible Investing: The ESG-Efficient Frontier.” Journal of Financial Economics, 142 (2021), 572–597.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ramelli, S., and Wagner, A. F.. “Feverish Stock Price Reactions to COVID-19.” Review of Corporate Finance Studies, 9 (2020), 622–655.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Renneboog, L.; Ter Horst, J.; and Zhang, C.. “Is Ethical Money Financially Smart? Nonfinancial Attributes and Money Flows of Socially Responsible Investment Funds.” Journal of Financial Intermediation, 20 (2011), 562–588.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Riedl, A., and Smeets, P.. “Why Do Investors Hold Socially Responsible Mutual Funds?” Journal of Finance, 72 (2017), 2505–2550.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sirri, E. R., and Tufano, P.. “Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows.” Journal of Finance, 53 (1998), 1589–1622.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spiegel, M., and Zhang, H.. “Mutual Fund Risk and Market Share-Adjusted Fund Flows.” Journal of Financial Economics, 108 (2013), 506–528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wang, A. Y., and Young, M.. “Terrorist Attacks and Investor Risk Preference: Evidence from Mutual Fund Flows.” Journal of Financial Economics, 137 (2020), 491–514.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Döttling and Kim supplementary material

Döttling and Kim supplementary material

Download Döttling and Kim supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 2 MB