Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-l4dxg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-04T23:59:39.284Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Storming the Citadels of Poverty: Family Planning under the Emergency in India, 1975–1977

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2014

Rebecca Jane Williams
Get access

Abstract

This article examines family planning during the Emergency in India, drawing upon the archive of the Shah Commission of Inquiry. It aims, primarily, to understand why family planning became such an important point of state intervention during the Emergency, when millions were sterilized. I argue that family planning was intended as a technocratic fix for the problem of poverty and that, although the family planning program existed before the Emergency, it received a fillip through Indira Gandhi's Emergency-era push for poverty eradication thanks to the established position of population control as a prerequisite for economic development. Secondly, it aims to understand how the Emergency and sterilization have become conflated in popular memory, such that the driving forces of poverty eradication and economic development have dropped out of the story altogether. The link between poverty eradication and population control has been forgotten, and a narrative of arbitrary family planning “excess” endured.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 73 , Issue 2 , May 2014 , pp. 471 - 492
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Agarwala, S. N. 1960. India's Population: Some Problems in Perspective Planning. London: Asia Publishing House.Google Scholar
Balfour, Marshall C. 1958. “Tentative List of Individuals and Institutions in Asia to Whom the Coale-Hoover Book Should be Sent.” Folder 388. Box 26. Record Group IV3B4.2. General File Series. Population Council Records. Rockefeller Archive Center, New York.Google Scholar
Balfour, Marshall C., Evans, Roger F., Notestein, Frank W., and Taeuber, Irene B.. 1950. Public Health and Demography in the Far East. New York: The Rockefeller Foundation.Google Scholar
Banerji, D. 1976. “Will Forcible Sterilization Be Effective?” Economic and Political Weekly 11(18):665–68.Google Scholar
Buckingham, Jane. 2006. “Patient Welfare vs. the Health of the Nation: Governmentality and Sterilization of Leprosy Sufferers in Early Post-Colonial India.” Social History of Medicine 19(3):483–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chakraborti, I. A. 1976. Note sent to S. C. Chaudhuri. September 28. File 1147. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Chandra, Bipan. 2003. In the Name of Democracy: J.P. Movement and the Emergency. New Delhi: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Chandra Sekhar, A. 1976. Letter to Chief Ministers. June 15. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Coale, Ansley J. 1958. Letter to Parker Mauldin. August 27. Folder 388. Box 26. Record Group IV3B4.2. General File Series. Population Council Records. Rockefeller Archive Center, New York.Google Scholar
Coale, Ansley J.. 2000. Ansley J. Coale: An Autobiography. Philadelphia, Pa.: American Philosophical Society.Google Scholar
Coale, Ansley J., and Hoover, Edgar M.. 1958. Population Growth and Economic Development in Low-Income Countries: A Case Study of India's Prospects. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Connelly, Matthew. 2006. “Population Control in India: Prologue to the Emergency Period.” Population and Development Review 32(4):629–67.Google Scholar
Connelly, Matthew. 2008. Fatal Misconception: The Struggle to Control World Population. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press.Google Scholar
Davis, Kingsley. 1951. The Population of India and Pakistan. New York: Russell & Russell.Google Scholar
Dayal, John, and Bose, Ajoy. 1978. The Shah Commission Begins. New Delhi: Orient Longman.Google Scholar
Finkle, Jason L., and Crane, Barbara B.. 1975. “The Politics of Bucharest: Population, Development, and the New International Economic Order.” Population and Development Review 1(1):87–114.Google Scholar
Furedi, Frank. 1997. Population and Development: A Critical Introduction. Cambridge, U.K.: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Gandhi, Indira. 1975. “Speech.” July 1. File 37/625/1975 PMS. Prime Minister's Office Files. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Gandhi, Indira. 1976. Letter to Chief Ministers. May 20. File 1199. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Gandhi, Indira. 1984. Selected Speeches and Writings of Indira Gandhi, Vol. III, September 1972-March 1977. New Delhi: Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.Google Scholar
Gangadharan, K., Koshy, P. J., and Radhakrishnan, C. N.. 1978. The Inquisition: Revelations before the Shah Commission. New Delhi: Path Publishers.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1961. Report of the Health Survey and Planning Committee. Vol. 1. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1964. Central Family Planning Board: Sixteenth Meeting at Bombay 1964. New Delhi: Ministry of Health.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1975a. Letter from Directorate of Health Services, Ahmedabad, to District Medical Officers. July 18. File 432. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1975b. “Family Welfare Planning Fortnight.” File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1976a. “Extracts from Weekly Reports of Intelligence Bureau Relating to Family Planning Campaign.” File 1200. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1976b. Circular from Directorate General of Health Services, Bangalore. November 4. File 439. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1976c. “Family Planning: The Vital Need Today.” File 444. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1977. “Reply to FP Questionnaire Received From M/O Health and Family Welfare.” File 1196. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Government of India. 1997. “Population in India's First Five-Year Plan (1951–56).” Population and Development Review 23(2):399–403.Google Scholar
Government of India. 2005. The Gazette of India Extraordinary, Part II, Section I, No. 25. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
Greenhalgh, Susan. 1996. “The Social Construction of Population Science: An Intellectual, Institutional, and Political History of Twentieth-Century Demography.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 38(1):26–66.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1975a. Letter dated August 12. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1975b. Letter dated November 12. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1976a. Letter to Directors of Health Services. January 9. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1976b. Letter to Directors of Health Services. July 28. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1977a. Letter to Chief Secretaries. January 4. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Grewal, Serla. 1977b. Letter to Chief Secretaries. February 19. File 1198. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Gwatkin, Davidson R. 1979. “Political Will and Family Planning: The Implications of India's Emergency Experience.” Population and Development Review 5(1):29–59.Google Scholar
Henderson, Michael. 1977. Experiment with Untruth. Delhi: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Hewitt, Vernon. 2008. Political Mobilisation and Democracy in India: States of Emergency. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hodges, Sarah. 2004. “Governmentality, Population and Reproductive Family in Modern India.” Economic and Political Weekly 39(11):1157–63.Google Scholar
Hodgson, Dennis. 1983. “Demography as Social Science and Policy Science.” Population and Development Review 9(1):1–34.Google Scholar
Indian Express. 2010. “Authorised Version: The Congress Tries to Rediscover Its History. But It Won't Let Anyone Else Do It for Them.” December 29. Chandigarh.Google Scholar
Indian Express. 2011. “Make Public 1975 Emergency Records: CIC.” June 15. http://www.indianexpress.com/news/make-public-1975-emergency-records-cic/804117/ (accessed August 17, 2011).Google Scholar
Indian National Congress. 2010. Congress and the Making of the Indian Nation. 2 vols. New Delhi: Academic Foundation.Google Scholar
Kaur, Rajkumari Amrit. 1954. Letter to DV Krishna Rao. January 4. Folder 14. Box 1. S. Chandrasekhar Papers. Ward M. Canaday Center for Special Collections, University of Toledo, Ohio.Google Scholar
Kelley, Allen C. 2001. “The Population Debate in Historical Perspective: Revisionism Revised.” In Population Matters: Demographic Change, Economic Growth, and Poverty in the Developing World, eds. Birdsall, Nancy, Kelley, Allen C., and Sinding, Steven W., 24–54. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Menon, Jaya. 2010. “A Few ‘Missing’ Emergency Files Found, Says NAI.” Times of India, September 2. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/6477858.cms (accessed January 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Mitta, Manoj. 2010. “Emergency Papers Found, Minus Indira Signature.” Times of India, December 10. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/7074117.cms (accessed January 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Nair, Rahul. 2006. “The Discourse on Population in India, 1870–1960.” Unpublished PhD diss., University of Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
Narasimhan, V. K. 1977. Democracy Redeemed. New Delhi: S. Chand & Co.Google Scholar
National Planning Committee. 1947. Population. Bombay: Vora & Co.Google Scholar
Nayar, Kuldip. 1977. The Judgement: Inside Story of the Emergency in India. New Delhi: Vikas.Google Scholar
Nehru, Jawaharlal. 1961. “Foreword.” In Population and Planned Parenthood in India, Chandrasekhar, S.. London: George Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
Notestein, Frank W. 1954. Letter to Marshall C. Balfour. April 13. Folder 5. Box 13. Ansley J. Coale Papers. Mudd Manuscript Library, Princeton University.Google Scholar
Notestein, Frank W.. 1955. Letter to Rajkumari Amrit Kaur. August 4. Folder 12. Box 14. Ansley J. Coale Papers. Mudd Manuscript Library, Princeton University.Google Scholar
Osborn, Frederick. 1959. Memo dated January 2. Folder 291. Box 17. Grant Files Series. Record Group IV3B4.2. Population Council Records. Rockefeller Archive Center, New York.Google Scholar
Paul, Sharda. 1977. 1977 General Elections in India. New Delhi: Associated Publishing House.Google Scholar
Population and Development Review. 1983. “Documents.” 9(4):747–53.Google Scholar
Prakash, Gian. 1975. Letter to Chief Secretaries. December 10. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Prakash, Gian. 1977. “Note on Family Planning Programme.” File 1195. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Rajagopal, Arvind. 2011. “The Emergency as Prehistory of the New Indian Middle Class.” Modern Asian Studies 45(5):1003–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ramachandran, V. 1977. Letter to State Governments. February 18. File 1198. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Rao, Mohan. 2004. From Population Control to Reproductive Health: Malthusian Arithmetic. New Delhi: Sage.Google Scholar
Roy, Ramashray. 1978. “The Sixth Lok Sabha Elections: A Systemic Perspective.” In The Meaning of the Indian Experience: The Emergency, ed. Chatterji, Saral K.37–48. Madras: Christian Literature Society.Google Scholar
Salas, Rafael. 1983. Letter to Theodore Schultz. August 25. Folder S-1051-0014-10. United Nations Documentation Centre. New York.Google Scholar
Scott, James C. 1998. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Sezhiyan, Era. 2010. Shah Commission Report: Lost, and Regained. Chennai: Aazhi Publishers.Google Scholar
Shah Commission of Inquiry. 1977. Note dated September 29. File 17. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Shah Commission of Inquiry. 1978a. “Summary: Implementation of the Family Planning Programme during the Emergency.” File 834. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Shah Commission of Inquiry. 1978b. “Witness: Dr. Karan Singh.” July 7. File 1280. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Shah Commission of Inquiry. 1978c. Interim Report I. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
Shah Commission of Inquiry. 1978d. Third and Final Report. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
Singh, Karan. 1975a. “Dr. Karan Singh's Speech in the Lok Sabha.” August 1. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Singh, Karan. 1975b. Letter No. 3520/MH(1)/75. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Singh, Karan. 1976. “National Population Policy Statement.” April 16. File 1194. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Singh, Karan. 1978. “Statement before the Shah Commission.” File 1342. Shah Commission of Inquiry Papers. National Archives of India.Google Scholar
Sinha, B. M. 1977. Operation Emergency. Delhi: Hind Pocket Books.Google Scholar
Szreter, Simon. 1993. “The Idea of Demographic Transition and the Study of Fertility Change: A Critical Intellectual History.” Population and Development Review 19(4):659–701.Google Scholar
Tarlo, Emma. 2000. “Body and Space in a Time of Crisis: Sterilization and Resettlement during the Emergency in Delhi.” In Violence and Subjectivity, ed. Das, Veena, 242–70. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Tarlo, Emma. 2003. Unsettling Memories: Narratives of the Emergency in Delhi. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Times of India. 1956. “Need for a Proper Approach Urged.” October 29. New Delhi.Google Scholar
Times of India. 2010. “‘30 Yrs On, Info on Emergency Cannot Be Official Secret.’” August 8. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/30-yrs-on-info-on-Emergency-cannot-be-official-secret/articleshow/6272901.cms (accessed January 1, 2011).Google Scholar
Vicziany, Marika. 1982. “Coercion in a Soft State: The Family-Planning Program of India: Part 1: The Myth of Voluntarism.” Pacific Affairs 55(3):373–402.Google Scholar
Vicziany, Marika. 1982–83. “Coercion in a Soft State: The Family-Planning Program of India: Part 2: The Sources of Coercion.” Pacific Affairs 55(4):557–92.Google Scholar
Weiner, Myron. 1978. India at the Polls: The Parliamentary Elections of 1977. Washington, D.C.: American Enterprise Institute for Policy Research.Google Scholar