Hostname: page-component-857557d7f7-wf4rb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-11-22T14:57:11.671Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Retribution Must Succeed Rebellion”: The Colonial Origins of Counterinsurgency Failure

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 April 2013

Paul K. MacDonald
Paul K. MacDonald*
Affiliation:
Wellesley College, Wellesley, Mass. E-mail: paul.k.macdonald@wellesley.edu
Get access

Abstract

What can explain the decline in incumbent victory in counterinsurgency wars? Political scientists offer a variety of explanations for these trends. Some focus on the structure and doctrine of counterinsurgent forces, while others emphasize the lethality and motivation of insurgent adversaries. I challenge these explanations. Declines in incumbent victory in counterinsurgency wars are not driven by fundamental shifts in the character of these conflicts, but in the political context in which they take place. Nineteenth-century colonial incumbents enjoyed a variety of political advantages—including strong political will, a permissive international environment, access to local collaborators, and flexibility to pick their battles—which granted them the time and resources necessary to meet insurgent challenges. In contrast, twentieth-century colonial incumbents struggled in the face of apathetic publics, hostile superpowers, vanishing collaborators, and constrained options. The decline in incumbent victory in counterinsurgency warfare, therefore, stems not from problems in force structure or strategy, but in political shifts in the profitability and legitimacy of colonial forms of governance.

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
International Organization , Volume 67 , Issue 2 , April 2013 , pp. 253 - 286
Copyright
Copyright © The IO Foundation 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Abernethy, David B. 2000. The Dynamics of Global Dominance: European Overseas Empires 1415–1980. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Andrade, Dale. 2008. Westmoreland Was Right: Learning the Wrong Lessons from the Vietnam War. Small Wars and Insurgencies 19 (2):145–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arreguín-Toft, Ivan. 2005. How the Weak Win Wars: A Theory of Asymmetric Conflict. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailes, Howard. 1980. Technology and Imperialism: A Case Study of the Victorian Army in Africa. Victorian Studies 24 (1):83–104.Google Scholar
Bailes, Howard. 1981. Patterns of Thought in the Late Victorian Army. Journal of Strategic Studies 4 (1):29–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bakker, J. I. 1993. The Aceh War and the Creation of the Netherlands East Indies State. In Great Powers and Little Wars: The Limits of Power, edited by Ion, A. Hamish and Errington, E.J., 53–82. Westport, Conn.: Praeger.Google Scholar
Beckett, Ian F. W. 2001. Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies: Guerillas and Their Opponents Since 1750. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beckett, Ian F. W. 2003. The Victorians at War. London: Hambledon and London.Google Scholar
Betts, Raymond F. 1985. Uncertain Dimensions: Western Overseas Empires in the Twentieth Century. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Bowden, Mark. 2001. Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War. New York: Penguin Putnam.Google Scholar
Byman, Daniel. 2008. An Autopsy of the Iraq Debacle: Policy Failure or Bridge Too Far? Security Studies 17 (4):599–643.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cain, P.J., and Hopkins, Anthony G.. 1993. British Imperialism: Crisis and Deconstruction, 1914–1990. New York: Longman.Google Scholar
Callwell, Charles Edward. 1996 [1899]. Small Wars: Their Principles and Practice. 3rd ed. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar
Clausewitz, Carl von. 1993 [1832]. On War. Edited and translated by Howard, Michael and Paret, Peter. New York: Knopf.Google Scholar
Clayton, Anthony. 1993. Hazou, Fazou, Tazou: Forest, Fire, and Fever—the French Occupation of Madagascar. In Great Powers and Little Wars: The Limits of Power, edited by Ion, A. Hamish and Errington, E.J., 83–104. Westport, Conn.: Praeger.Google Scholar
Cohen, Eliot A. 1984. Constraints on America's Conduct of Small Wars. International Security 9 (2):151–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colonial Office. Papers. British National Archives, Public Records Office, London.Google Scholar
Darwin, John. 1988. Britain and Decolonisation: The Retreat from Empire in the Post-War World. London: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Darwin, John. 1991. The End of the British Empire: The Historical Debate. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Darwin, John. 1997. Imperialism and the Victorians: The Dynamics of Territorial Expansion. English Historical Review 112 (447):614–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Desai, Raj, and Eckstein, Harry. 1990. Insurgency: The Transformation of Peasant Rebellion. World Politics 42 (4):441–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Downes, Alexander. 2006. Desperate Times, Desperate Measures: The Causes of Civilian Victimization in War. International Security 30 (4):152–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Doyle, Michael W. 1986. Empires. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Etemad, Bouda. 2007. Possessing the World: Taking the Measurements of Colonisation from the Eighteenth to the Twentieth Century. New York: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
Fearon, James D., and Laitin, David D.. 2003. Ethnicity, Insurgency, and Civil War. American Political Science Review 97 (1):75–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fieldhouse, David Kenneth. 1973. Economics and Empire, 1830–1914. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Foreign Office. Papers. British National Archives, Public Records Office, London.Google Scholar
Galbraith, John S. 1960. The “Turbulent Frontier” as a Factor in British Expansion. Comparative Studies in Society and History 2 (2):150–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Galbraith, John S. 1963. Reluctant Empire: British Policy on the South African Frontier, 1834–1854. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Galula, David. 1964. Counterinsurgency Warfare: Theory and Practice. Westport, Conn.: Praeger Security International.Google Scholar
Gartzke, Erik, and Rohner, Dominic. 2011. The Political Economy of Imperialism, Decolonization and Development. British Journal of Political Science 41 (3):525–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guy, J.J. 1971. A Note on Firearms in the Zulu Kingdom with Special Reference to the Anglo-Zulu War, 1879. Journal of African History 12 (4):557–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hack, Karl. 2009. The Malayan Emergency as Counter-Insurgency Paradigm. Journal of Strategic Studies 32 (3):383–414.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamley, Edward Bruce. 1878. The Operations of War: Explained and Illustrated. 4th ed. London: William Blackwood and Sons.Google Scholar
Heathcote, T.A. 1995. The Military in British India: The Development of British Land Forces in South Asia, 1600–1947. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Herbst, Jeffrey. 2000. States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Hyam, Ronald. 1976. Britain's Imperial Century 1815–1914: A Study of Empire and Expansion. London: B.T. Batsford.Google Scholar
Jervis, Jervis-White. 1852. Manual of Field Operations. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Kaldor, Mary. 2006. New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
Kalyvas, Stathis N. 2001. “New” and “Old” Civil Wars: A Valid Distinction? World Politics 54 (1):99–118.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalyvas, Stathis N. 2006. The Logic of Violence in Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalyvas, Stathis N. 2008. Collaboration in Comparative Perspective. European Review of History 15 (2):109–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalyvas, Stathis, and Balcells, Laila. 2010. The International System and Technologies of Rebellion: How the End of the Cold War Shaped Internal Conflict. American Political Science Review 104 (3):415–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kane, Tim. 2004. Global U.S. Troop Deployment, 1950–2003. Washington, D.C.: Heritage Foundation.Google Scholar
Kanya-Forstner, A.S. 1989. The French Marines and the Conquest of the Western Sudan, 1880–1899. In Imperialism and War: Essays on Colonial Wars in Asia and Africa, edited by de Moor, J.A. and Wesseling, H.L., 121–45. Leiden, The Netherlands: E.J. Brill.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keene, Edward. 2002. Beyond the Anarchical Society: Grotius, Colonialism and Order in World Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kilcullen, David. 2006/2007. Counter-Insurgency Redux. Survival: Global Politics and Strategy 48 (4):111–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Killingray, David. 1989. Colonial Warfare in West Africa 1870–1914. In Imperialism and War: Essays on Colonial Wars in Asia and Africa, edited by de Moor, J.A. and Wesseling, H.L., 146–67. Leiden, The Netherlands: E.J. Brill.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koskenniemi, Martti. 2001. The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International Law 1870–1960. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Krepinevich, Andrew F. 1988. The Army and Vietnam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Lange, Matthew, Mahoney, James, and vom Hau, Matthias. 2006. Colonialism and Development: A Comparative Analysis of Spanish and British Colonies. American Journal of Sociology 111 (5):1412–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laqueur, Walter. 1976. Guerrilla: A Historical and Critical Study. Boston: Little and Brown.Google Scholar
Lonsdale, J.M. 1977. The Politics of Conquest: The British in Western Kenya, 1894–1908. Historical Journal 20 (4):841–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lyall, Jason, and Wilson, Isaiah. 2009. Rage Against the Machines: Explaining Outcomes in Counterinsurgency Wars. International Organization 63 (1):67–106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lynn, John. 1993. The History of Logistics and Supplying War. In Feeding Mars: Logistics in Western Warfare from the Middle Ages to the Present, edited by Lynn, John A., 9–27. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Mack, Andrew. 1975. Why Big Nations Lose Small Wars: The Politics of Asymmetric Conflict. World Politics 27 (2):175–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Manela, Erez. 2007. The Wilsonian Moment: Self-Determination and the International Origins of Anticolonial Nationalism. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mann, Michael. 2004. The First Failed Empire of the Twenty-First Century. Review of International Studies 30 (4):631–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mann, Michael. 2005. Incoherent Empire. New York: Verso.Google Scholar
McNeill, William H. 1982. The Pursuit of Power: Technology, Armed Force, and Society since A.D. 1000. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merom, Gil. 2003. How Democracies Lose Small Wars: State, Society, and the Failures of France in Algeria, Israel in Lebanon, and the United States in Vietnam. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mueller, John. 2004. Remnants of War. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Nagl, John A. 2005. Learning to Eat Soup with a Knife: Counterinsurgency Lessons from Malaya and Vietnam. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Newbury, Colin. 2003. Patrons, Clients, and Empire: Chieftaincy and Over-Rule in Asia, Africa, and the Pacific. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parliamentary Papers. Harvard College Library, Boston. Available at ⟨http://parlipapers.chadwyck.co.uk⟩. Accessed 22 February 2008.Google Scholar
Peers, Douglas M. 1997. Introduction. In Warfare and Empires: Contact and Conflict Between European and Non-European Military and Maritime Forces and Cultures, edited by Peers, Douglas M., xv–xxxiv. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Porch, Douglas. 2000. Wars of Empire. London: Cassell.Google Scholar
Porter, A.N., and Stockwell, A.J.. 1987. British Imperial Policy and Decolonization 1938–1964. New York: St. Martin's Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roberts, Andrew D. 1962. The Sub-Imperialism of the Baganda. Journal of African History 3 (3):435–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Robinson, Ronald. 1972. Non-European Foundations of European Imperialism: Sketch for a Theory of Collaboration. In Studies in the Theory of Imperialism, edited by Owen, Roger and Sutcliffe, Robert B., 117–140. London: Longman.Google Scholar
Rosen, Stephen Peter. 1982. Vietnam and the American Theory of Limited War. International Security 7 (2):83–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simpson, Erin M. 2010. The Perils of Third-Party Counterinsurgency Campaigns. Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Spiers, Edward M. 1992. The Late Victorian Army, 1868–1902. Oxford, UK: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Spruyt, Hendrik. 2005. Ending Empire: Contested Sovereignty and Territorial Partition. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Strachan, Hew. 1985. From Waterloo to Balaclava: Tactics, Technology, and the British Army, 1815–1854. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Strachan, Hew. 1997. The Politics of the British Army. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Strang, David. 1991. Global Patterns of Decolonization, 1500–1987. International Studies Quarterly 35 (4):429–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Switzer, Les. 1993. Power and Resistance in an African Society: The Ciskei Xhosa and the Making of South Africa. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Valentino, Benjamin, Huth, Paul, and Balch-Lindsay, Dylan. 2004. “Draining the Sea”: Mass Killing and Guerilla Warfare. International Organization 58 (2):375–407.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valentino, Benjamin, Huth, Paul, and Croco, Sarah. 2006. Covenants Without the Sword: International Law and the Protection of Civilians in Times of War. World Politics 58 (3):339–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
War Office. Papers. British National Archives, Public Records Office, London.Google Scholar
Weinstein, Jeremy M. 2007. Inside Rebellion: The Politics of Insurgent Violence. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
West, Bing. 2005. No True Glory: A Frontline Account of the Battle for Fallujah. New York: Bantam Dell.Google Scholar
Yates, Edward. 1855. Elementary Treatise on Tactics and on Certain Parts of Strategy. London: T. and W. Boone.Google Scholar
Young, Crawford. 1994. The African Colonial State in Comparative Perspective. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.Google Scholar