Hostname: page-component-7857688df4-lffn4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-11-17T03:36:44.771Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

William Herschel, Bath, and the Philosophical Society

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 April 2016

Roy Porter
Roy Porter*
Affiliation:
Wellcome Institute for the History of Medicine, London

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Richard Brinsley Sheridan, a Bathonian, opens his comedy, The Rivals, with a social sneer. Fag, the stylish apostle of bon ton, meets his fellow servant Thomas, a clodhopping yokel, and exclaims: “Why Thomas … But who the deuce thought of seeing you in Bath?”. One might ask the same of William Herschel, the Hanoverian bandsman’s son, who, having discovered Uranus, was to pass the last forty years of his life as a Crown pensionary, living just outside Windsor. How did Herschel come to spend his formative scientific years in Bath, resort of the giddy and the gay? How did he come to discover Uranus there?

Information

Type
History of the Discovery of Uranus
Information
International Astronomical Union Colloquium , Volume 60: Uranus and the Outer Planets , 1982 , pp. 23 - 34
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1982

References

1. Cf. Lubbock, C.A. (ed.), The Herschel chronicle (Cambridge, 1933), passim; Hoskin, M.A., William Herschel, pioneer of sidereal astronomy (London, 1959).Google Scholar
2. Wrigley, A.E., “A simple model of London’s importance in changing English society and economy, 1650–1750”, Past and present, xxxvi (1967), 44–70; Fisher, F.J., “The development of London as a centre of conspicuous consumption in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries”, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society. xxx (1948), 37–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
3. [Goldsmith, Oliver], The life of Richard Nash of Bath (London and Bath, 1762), 21. Cf. Lennard, R. (ed.), Englishmen at rest and play (Oxford, 1931), 47f.Google Scholar
4. Quoted in Kite, V.J., Libraries in Bath, 1618–1964 (thesis for fellowship of the Library Association, 1966), 12, from Fleming, F., Life and adventures of Timothy Ginnadrake (3 vols, Bath, 1771), iii, 15. For a necessary corrective, bringing out the genuine vitality of seventeenth century Bath, see P. Rowland James, The baths of Bath in the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries (London, 1938). Nevertheless it is important to note how impressed were eighteenth century commentators with the rate, extent, and glory of Bath’s current development. For introductions to the Georgian municipal growth of Bath see Little, B., Bath portrait (2nd ed., Bristol, 1968), and Maclntyre, Sylvia, “Towns as health and pleasure resorts: Bath, Scarborough and Weymouth, 1770–1815” (D.Phil, thesis, Oxford University, 1973).Google Scholar
5. Lewis, W.S. (ed.), Horace Walpole’s correspondence, xi (New Haven, 1944), 288.Google Scholar
6. These beliefs were well articulated by Wood, John the Elder, the Bath architect; for which see Neale, Ron, “Society, belief, and the building of Bath, 1700–1793”, in Chalklin, C.W. and Havinden, M.A. (eds), Rural change and urban growth, 1500–1800 (London, 1974), 252–80. For Enlightenment respect for urban culture, see Schorske, C.E., “The idea of the city in European thought, Voltaire to Spengler”, in Handlin, O. and Burchard, J. (eds), The historian and the city (Cambridge, Mass., 1966), 95–114.Google Scholar
7. Cranefield, G.A., The development of the provincial newspaper, 1700–1760 (Oxford, 1926); Wiles, R. McK., Freshest advices (Columbus, Ohio, 1965).Google Scholar
8. See the suggestive remarks in Rothblatt, S., Tradition and change in English liberal education (London, 1976), ch.iv, ‘London’.Google Scholar
9. Wood, J., An essay towards a description of Bath, 2 vols. (London, 1749), 439–40; and more generally Plumb, J.H., The commercialization of leisure in eighteenth century England (Reading, 1973); Money, J., Experience and identity, Birmingham and the West Midlands, 1760–1800 (Manchester, 1977); Read, D., The English provinces, c.1760–1960 (London, 1964); Borsay, P., “The English urban renaissance: the development of provincial urban culture, c. 1680–1760”, Social history, vi (1977), 581–603; Clark, P. and Slack, P., English towns in transition 1500–1700 (Oxford, 1975). For a contemporary reflection, see “Present state of the manners, society, etc., etc., of the metropolis of England”, Monthly magazine, x (1800), 35–38.Google Scholar
10. For Hippisley, see Barbeau, A., Life and letters at Bath in the xviii century (London, 1904), 65. For a good account of relations between London and provincial theatre see Hare, A., The Georgian theatre in Wessex (London, 1958).Google Scholar
11. Quoted in Read, op.cit. (ref. 9), 18–19.Google Scholar
12. Quoted in Clark, and Slack, , op.cit. (ref. 9), 156.Google Scholar
13. Rev. Nightingale, J., The beauties of England and Wales, xii (London, 1813), 427.Google Scholar
14. Egan, Pierce, Walks through Bath (Bath, 1819), 58.Google Scholar
15. Quoted in The book of Bath, written for the 93rd annual meeting of the British Medical Association (Bath, 1925), 79. Spas developed as a pioneer form of leisure resort, since they already had long existed as medical centres. Addison, W., English spas (London, 1951); Gadd, D., Georgian summer: Bath in the eighteenth century (London, 1970).Google Scholar
16. See for instance, Pimlott, J.A.R., The Englishman’s holiday (London, 1947); and Patmore, J.A., “The spa towns of Britain”, in Beckinsale, R.P. and Houston, J.M. (eds), Urbanization and its problems (Oxford, 1968), 47–55.Google Scholar
17. Quoted in Mare, M.L. and Quarrell, W.H., Lichtenberg’s visits to England (Oxford, 1938), 95.Google Scholar
18. Barbeau, , op.cit. (ref. 10), 111.Google Scholar
19. For itinerant scientific lecturers see Gibbs, F.W., “Itinerant lecturers in natural philosophy”, Ambix, vi (1960), 111–17; Musson, A.E. and Robinson, E., Science and technology in the Industrial Revolution (Manchester, 1969), which inter alia charts the movement of science from London into the provinces. See also Rowbottcm, M., “The teaching of experimental philosophy in England, 1700–1730”, Actes du XIe congrès internationale d’histoire des sciences, iv (Warsaw, 1968), 46–53. See Henderson, E., Life of James Ferguson, F.R.S. (Edinburgh, 1867), 268, 278, 338, 407. Ferguson’s Astronomy may have been the first astronomy text Herschel purchased. See Lubbock, , op.cit. (ref. 1), 60. See also Millburn, J.R., Benjamin Martin: author, instrument-maker, and ‘country showman’ (Leyden, 1276).Google Scholar
20. [Goldsmith, ], op.cit. (ref. 3), 46.Google Scholar
21. Hudson, K., The Bath and West (Bradford-on-Avon, 1976).Google Scholar
22. Torrens, H., “Geological communication in the Bath area in the last half of the eighteenth century”, in Jordanova, L.J. and Porter, Roy S. (eds), Images of the earth (Chalfont St. Giles, Bucks, 1979), 215–47.Google Scholar
23. Murch, J., Bath physicians of former times (Bath, 1882). For a taste of the balneological war, see Baylies, W., Practical reflections on the uses and abuses of Bath waters (London, 1757); idem, A narrative of facts, demonstrating the actual existence and true cause of that physical confederacy in Bath (London, 1757); idem, An historical account of the rise, progress and management of the General Hospital and Infirmary in the City of Bath (Bath, 1758); for a bibliography of it see Mullett, C.F., “Public baths and health in England, 16th-18th century”, Supplements to the Bulletin of the history of medicine, v (Baltimore, 1946), 1–85.Google Scholar
24. Turner, A.J., Catalogue to an exhibition, “Science and Music in eighteenth century Bath” (Bath, 1977); Hunter, J., The connexion of Bath with the literature and science of England (Bath, 1853), 81–83.Google Scholar
25. Porter, Roy, “Science, provincial culture and public opinion in Enlightenment England”, The British journal for eighteenth century studies, iii (1980), 20–46.Google Scholar
26. See Hunter, , op.cit. (ref. 24). Of course, other fashionable centres like York and Norwich could not boast scientific societies at all. But my point is that such societies when founded in Birmingham, Manchester, Edinburgh, etc. went from strength to strength whereas in Bath they languished.Google Scholar
27. See above all Thackray, A.W., “Natural knowledge in cultural context: the Manchester model”, American historical review, lxxix (1974), 672–709, p.685: “the medical profession as guardian of the polite virtues in an industrializing world”. For an important exploration of the interface between the medical and literary worlds see Rousseau, G.S., “Matt Bramble and the sulphur controversy in the XVIIIth century”, Journal of the history of ideas, xxviii (1967), 577–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
28. Pack’s, Edmund “A disultory journal of events &c. at Bath” (Bath Reference Library R69/12675) for 1779 well expresses his own envy and disgust towards fashionable Bath society. For published expression of Rack’s views and values see his Poems on several subjects (Bath and London, 1775), and his Mentor’s letters (Bath and London, 1778), 23f. For a contemporary characterization of Rackas a petit bourgeois social climber see [?P. Thicknesse], Edmund: an ecloque (n.p., n.d.), 8:Google Scholar
29. Herschel’s papers to the Society are listed in Dreyer, J.L.E., The scientific papers of Sir William Herschel, 2 vols (London, 1912), i, pp.lxv–lxvi.Google Scholar