Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-g4j75 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-04T09:45:33.316Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Older Workers and Requests for Flexibility: A Weak Right in the Face of Entrenched Age Discrimination

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2025

Therese MacDermott
Therese MacDermott*
Affiliation:
Macquarie Law School, Macquarie University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In 2013, the right to request flexible work arrangements was extended to include employees who are 55 years or older, with a refusal by an employer of such a request in theory available only on the basis of ‘reasonable business grounds.’ This expansion of the right to request is one of a number of different strategies implemented with a view to enhancing the workforce participation of older Australians. This paper examines the scope of the right to request and how it operates with respect to older workers as part of the National Employment Standards in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The paper also examines the gender dimension in the making of requests and in the utilisation of flexible work practices. Since the ‘right’ exists as merely the subject for negotiation at a workplace level, rather than an enforceable claim, this paper contends that it is unable to overcome persistent and prevalent age discrimination in employment. The paper argues that a review process and independent oversight are required in order to bring about the attitudinal change necessary if the right to request flexible work arrangements is to operate as a viable means of providing constructive opportunities for older workers to maintain their workforce participation.

Type
Article
Information
Federal Law Review , Volume 44 , Issue 3 , September 2016 , pp. 451 - 466
Copyright
Copyright © 2016 The Australian National University

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Thanks to Professor Denise Meyerson for her invaluable advice and mentoring, and to the anonymous referees for their helpful comments and suggestions.

References

1 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 65.

2 Commonwealth, 2015 Intergenerational Report, Australia in 2055, (Intergenerational Report, Treasury, 2015).Google Scholar Austen, Siobhan and Ong, Rachel, ‘The Effects of Ill Health and Informal Care Roles On the Employment Retention of Mid-life Women: Does the Workplace Matter?’ (2013) 55(5) Journal of Industrial Relations 663, 664.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 See MacDermott, Therese, ‘Older Workers and Extended Workforce Participation: Moving Beyond the “Barriers to Work” Approach’ (2014) 14(2) International Journal of Discrimination and the Law 83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Temple, Jeromey, Adair, Tim and Chavoshi, Meimanat, ‘Ageing and the Barriers to Labour Force Participation in Australia’ (Report, National Seniors Productive Ageing Centre, 13 December 2011) 23.Google Scholar

5 Billett, Stephen et al, ‘Last Resort Employees: Older Workers’ Perceptions of Workplace Discrimination’ (2011) 14(4) Human Resources Development International 375CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Billett, Stephen et al, ‘Overcoming the Paradox of Employers’ Views About Older Workers’ (2011) 22(6) International Journal of Human Resource Management 1248.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

6 Coverage of age was introduced into anti-discrimination legislation in South Australia (1990), Queensland (1992), Western Australia (1993), New South Wales (1994), Northern Territory (1994), Australian Capital Territory (1996), Victoria (1996) Tasmania (1999), and to the federal system (2004): see Encel, Sol, ‘Age Discrimination in Law and in Practice’ (2004) 3 Elder Law Review 13.Google Scholar

7 Australian Human Rights Commission, National Prevalence Survey of Age Discrimination in the Workplace (2015) 3.

8 Ibid.

9 Australian Human Rights Commission, Willing to Work: National Inquiry into Employment Discrimination against Older Workers and Australians with Disability (2016).

10 Ibid 77.

11 Fair Work Amendment Act 2013 (Cth).

12 (2005) 143 IR 245.

13 Charlesworth, Sara and Campbell, Iain, ‘Right to Request Regulation: Two New Australian Models’ (2008) 21(2) Australian Journal of Labour Law 116, 122.Google Scholar

14 Workplace Relations Amendment (Work Choices) Act 2005 (Cth).

15 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 65.

16 Ibid s 65(1).

17 See Fair Work Act Review Panel, ‘Towards More Productive and Equitable Workplaces: An Evaluation of the Fair Work Legislation’ (Department of Employment, Education and Workplace Relations, 2012) 99 <http://docs.employment.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/towards_more_productive_and_equitable_workplaces_an_evaluation_of_the_fair_work_legislation.pdf>.

18 Explanatory Memorandum, Fair Work Amendment Bill 2013 (Cth) 10.

19 Other non-care based entitlements under this provision include that the employee has a disability or the employee is experiencing violence or supporting a member of the employee's family or household experiencing violence.

20 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 65(2)(a).

21 Ibid s 65(2)(b).

22 Ibid s 65(4).

23 Ibid s 65(5A).

24 Employment Rights Act 1996 (UK) s 80F.

25 Department of Business Innovations and Skills, Consultation on Modern Workplaces (2011) 6 [10].

26 Grabham, Emily, ‘Legal Form and Temporal Rationalities in the UK Work-Life Balance Law’ (2014) 29(79) Australian Feminist Studies 67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

27 Department of Business Innovations and Skills, above n 25, 6 [12].

28 Confederation of British Industry, Business Still Needs to Do More on Flexible Working (26 November 2014) CBI News <http://news.cbi.org.uk/news/business-still-need-to-do-more-on-flexible-working/>.

29 Silim, Amna and Stirling, Alfie, ‘Women and Flexible Working: Improving Female Employment Outcomes in Europe’ (Report, Institute of Public Policy Research, December 2014).Google Scholar

30 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Disability, Ageing and Carers, Australia: Summary of Findings, Cat No 4430.0 (2012).

31 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Labour Force, Australia, Cat No 6291.0.55.00 (2016).

32 Commonwealth, above n 2.

33 New South Wales Government, NSW Intergenerational Report: Future State NSW 2056 (Intergenerational Report, NSW Treasury, 2016) 7.Google Scholar

34 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Labour Force, Australia, above n 31.

35 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Retirement and Retirement Intentions, Australia, July 2014 to June 2015, Cat No 6238.0 (2016).

36 With a retirement age of 58.2 years for men and 51.5 years for women: ibid.

37 Ibid.

38 Ibid.

39 Tim Adair and Emma Lourey, ‘Disengagement of Mature Age People From the Labour Force: Reasons, Financial Outcomes and Access to Training, (Report, National Seniors Productive Ageing Centre, 2014) using data from the 2011 Census of Population and Housing; the 2008-2009 Multipurpose Household Survey, and the 2011-2012 Barriers to Employment for Mature Aged Australians Survey.

40 Austen and Ong, above n 2, 665. See also Dow, Briony and Meyer, Claudia ‘Caring and Retirement: Crossroads and Consequences’ (2010) 40(4) International Journal of Health Services 645, 649–50.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

41 Loretto, Wendy, and Vickerstaff, Sarah, ‘The Domestic and Gendered Context For Retirement’ (2013) 66(1) Human Relations 65CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Vickerstaff, Sarah et al, ‘Encouraging Labour Market Activity Among 60-64 Year Olds’ (Research Report No 531, Department for Work and Pensions, 2008).Google Scholar

42 Australian Workplace Relations Survey, First Findings Report (2014) ch 6. The survey showed that 37% of women workers considered flexibility to be the most important aspect of employment, compared to men (26%).

43 Loretto, Wendy, Vickerstaff, Sarah and White, Phil, ‘Flexible Work and Older Workers’ in Loretto, Wendy, Vickerstaff, Sarah and White, Phil (eds), The Future of Older Workers: New Perspectives (The Policy Press, 2007) 139.Google Scholar

44 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Retirement and Retirement Intentions, Australia, July 2014 to June 2015, Cat No 6238.0 (2016).

45 Ibid.

46 Advisory Panel on the Economic Potential of Senior Australians, Realising the Economic Potential of Older Australians—Turning Grey into Gold (2011) 24.

47 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Disability, Ageing and Carers, Australia: Summary of Findings, Cat No 4430.0 (2012).

48 Ibid.

49 House of Representative Standing Committee on Family, Community, Housing and Youth, Who Cares…? Report of the Inquiry Into Better Support for Carers, No 100 of 2009, 1 May 2009, 27 [2.45].

50 Ibid 28 [2.47].

51 Australian Human Right Commission, It's About Time: Women Men, Work and Family, Final Paper (2007) ch 4.

52 See Catherine Earl and Philip Taylor, ‘Is Workplace Flexibility Good Policy? Evaluating the Efficacy of Age Management Strategies for Older Women Workers’ (2015) Work Aging and Retirement 1, <http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/workar/wau012wau012>; Lewis, Susan and Humbert, Anne Laure, ‘Discourse or Reality? “Work-life Balance”, Flexible Working Polices, and the Gendered Organisation’ (2010) 29(3) Equality, Diversity and Inclusion 239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

53 Gaze, Beth, ‘Quality Part-Time Work: Can the Law Provide a Framework?’ (2005) 15 Labour and Industry 89CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Chalmers, Jenny and Hill, Trish, ‘Marginalising Women in the Labour Market: “Wage Scarring” Effects of Part-time Work’ (2007) 33 Australian Bulletin of Labour 180Google Scholar; Phillipson, Chris, ‘Extending Working Life and Re-defining Retirement: Problems and Challenges for Social Policy’ in Ennals, Richard and Salomon, Robert (eds), Older Workers in a Sustainable Society (Peter Lang, 2011) 233, 240.Google Scholar

54 Natalie Skinner, Claire Hutchinson and Barbara Pocock, Centre for Work-Life, University of South Australia, Australian Work and Life Index - The Big Squeeze: Work Home and Care in 2012, Australian Work and Life Index (2012).

55 Australian Bureau of Statistics, Employee Earnings and Hours, Australia, May 2014, Cat No 6306.0 (2015).

56 Yerkes, Mara, ‘Part-time work in the Dutch Welfare State: the Ideal Combination of Work and Care?’ (2009) 7(4) Policy & Politics 535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

57 Owens, Rosemary, ‘Engendering Flexibility in a World of Precarious Work’ in Fudge, Judy and Owens, Rosemary (eds), Precarious Work, Women, and the New Economy: The Challenge to Legal Norms (Hart Publishing, 2006) 229, 229.Google Scholar See also Owens, Rosemary, ‘Women, “Atypical” Work Relationships and the Law’ (1993) 19 Melbourne University Law Review 399.Google Scholar

58 Australian Human Right Commission, Investing in Care: Recognising and Valuing Those Who Care, Research Report: Volume 1 (2013) 13–14.Google Scholar

59 Craig, Lyn and Jenkins, Bridget, ‘Grandparent Childcare in Australia: Gender Differences in the Correlates of Providing Regular Grandparent Care While Parents Work’ (2015) 19(3) Community, Work & Family 281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

60 Gray, Matthew and Tudball, Jaqueline, ‘Family Friendly Work Practices: Differences within and Between Workplaces’ (2003) 45 Journal of Industrial Relations 269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar See also Phillipson, Chris, ‘Is Extending Working Life Possible? Research and Policy Issue’ in Loretto, Wendy, Vickerstaff, Sarah and White, Phil (eds), The Future of Older Workers: New Perspectives (The Policy Press, 2007) 185, 194Google Scholar; Vickerstaff et al, ‘Encouraging Labour Market Activity Among 60-64 Year Olds’, above n 41, 5.

61 Eurofound Sustainable Work and the Ageing Workforce, (Publications Office of the European Union, 2012)Google Scholar; Hirsch, Donald, ‘Sustaining Working Lives: the Challenge of Retention’ in Loretto, Wendy, Vickerstaff, Sarah and White, Phil (eds), The Future of Older Workers: New Perspectives (The Policy Press, 2007) 103.Google Scholar

62 Lester, Gillian, ‘Age Discrimination and Labour Law in the United States’ in Numhauser-Henning, Ann and Rönnmar, Mia (eds), Age Discrimination in Labour Law (Kluwer Law International, 2015) 399.Google Scholar

63 Austen, Siobhan et al, ‘Care Roles and Employment Decision-Making: the Effect of Economic Circumstances’ (2015) 57(5) Journal of Industrial Relations 665.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

64 Ibid 675–6.

65 Dow, Briony and Meyer, Claudia, ‘Caring and Retirement: Crossroads and Consequences’ (2010) 40(4) International Journal of Health Services 645, 651.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

66 McCann, Deirdre, Regulating Flexible Work (Oxford University Press, 2008) 176.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

67 Taylor, Phillip, ‘Is Early Retirement History?’ in Ennals, Richard and Salomon, Robert (eds), Older Workers in a Sustainable Society (Peter Lang, 2011) 225, 228.Google Scholar

68 Bernadette O’Neill, ‘General Manager's Report Into the Operation of the Provisions of the National Employment Standards Relating to Requests for Flexible Working Arrangements and Extensions of Unpaid Parental Leave Under s.653 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)’ (General Manager's Reports, Fair Work Commission, November 2015).

69 Ibid 19.

70 Ibid 20.

71 Ibid 26.

72 Ibid 25.

73 Ibid 27.

74 Ibid.

75 Ibid.

76 Ibid 35.

77 Barbara Pocock, Sara Charlesworth and Janine Chapman, ‘Work-family and Work-life Pressure in Australia: Advancing Gender Equality in “Good Times”?’ (2013) 33(9/10) International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 594, 601-2. See also Australian Workplace Relations Survey, above n 42.

78 Cooper, Rae and Baird, Marian, ‘Bringing the “Right to Request” Flexible Work Arrangements to Life: From Policies to Practices’ (2015) 37(5) Employee Relations 568.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

79 Ibid; Skinner, Hutchinson and Pocock, above n 54, 10.

80 Palmer, Tom, ‘Results of the First Flexible Working Employee Survey’ (Employment Relations Occasional Papers, United Kingdom Department of Trade and Industry, April 2004)Google Scholar; Grainger, Heidi and Holt, Heather, ‘Results of the Second Flexible Work Employee Survey’ (Employment Relations Research Series No 3, United Kingdom Department of Trade and Industry, July 2005)Google Scholar; Hooker, Hülya et al, ‘The Third Work Life Balance Employee Survey: Main Findings’ (Employment Relations Research Series No 58, United Kingdom Department of Trade and Industry, March 2007)Google Scholar; Tipping, Sarah et al, ‘The Fourth Work Life Balance Employee Survey’ (Employment Relations Research Series No 122, United Kingdom Department for Business Innovation and Skills, July 2012).Google Scholar

81 Barrett, Brenda and Sargeant, Malcolm, ‘Working in the UK Without a Default Retirement Age: Health, Safety, and the Oldest Workers’ (2015) 44(1) Industrial Law Journal 75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

82 Vanessa Beck, ‘Employers’ Views of Learning and Training For an Ageing Workforce’ (2012) Management Learning 200; Canduela, Jesus et al, ‘Ageing, Skills and Participation in Work-related Training in Britain: Assessing the Position of Older Workers’ (2012) 26(1) Work Employment & Society 42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

83 Eurofound, above n 61.

84 See Australian Workplace Relations Survey, above n 42.

85 Fair Work Act s 739(2).

86 Australian Human Rights Commission, Willing to Work, above n 9, 341.

87 In the UK, the legislation provided a mechanism to challenge the accuracy of the factual basis for a refusal. However, the specific procedural requirements that were originally imposed in the UK system, which could be adjudicated on in tribunal proceedings, have been replaced with a general requirement that employers deal with an application ‘in a reasonable manner’.

88 See, eg, Poppy v Service to Youth Council Incorporated (2014) 318 ALR 195; Stanley v Service to Youth Council Incorporated (2014) 225 FCR 317; Cavar v St Brigid's trading as Green Gate Pty Ltd [2015] FCCA 1993 (24 July 2015); Chapman, Anna, ‘Is the Right to Request Flexibility Under the Fair Work Act Enforceable?’ (2013) 26(2) Australian Journal of Labour Law 118.Google Scholar

89 Fair Work Act Review Panel, above n 17, 96.

90 Owens, Rosemary, ‘Engendering Flexibility in a World of Precarious Work’ in Fudge, Judy and Owens, Rosemary (eds), Precarious Work, Women, and the New Economy: The Challenge to Legal Norms (Hart Publishing, 2006) 329, 351.Google Scholar

91 Menkel-Meadow, Carrie, ‘Towards Another View of Legal Negotiation: The Structure of Problem Solving’ (1983) 31(4) University of California Los Angeles Law Review 754.Google Scholar

92 See Reichborn-Kjennerud, Kristen, Gampoeriene, Migle and Hilsen, Anne Inga, ‘“Make Me an Offer I Can't Refuse”—Do Extra Days Off Contribute to Seniors Staying at Work Longer?’ in Ennals, Richard and Salomon, Robert (eds), Older Workers in a Sustainable Society (Peter Lang, 2011) 209.Google Scholar

93 Charlesworth and Campbell, above n 13, 135. Cf Chapman, above n 88.

94 Anderson, Lucy, ‘Sound Bite Legislation: The Employment Act 2002 and the New Flexible Rights For Parents’ (2003) 32(1) Industrial Law Journal 37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

95 Coucher, Richard and Kelliher, Clare, ‘The Right to Request Flexible Working in Britain: The Law and Organisational Realities’ (2005) 21(3) International Journal of Comparative Labour law and Industrial Relations 503, 507Google Scholar; Himmelweit, Sue, ‘The Right to Request Flexible Working; A “Very British” Approach to Gender (in) Equality?’ (2007) 33(2) Australian Bulletin of Labour 246.Google Scholar

96 See Skinner, Hutchinson and Pocock, above n 54.

97 O’Neill, above n 68, 35.