Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-g4j75 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-11T02:03:08.522Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Fourteenth-Century Pulpitum Screen at Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 August 2014

Stuart A. Harrison ,
Richard K. Morris  and
David M. Robinson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Tintern is one of the best-known monastic sites in the British Isles, even if its architectural history is less well understood than assertions in the general literature might suggest. This study focusses upon a distinct group of ex situ masonry fragments until recently dispersed across the site. As reconstructed on paper, the material represents the remarkable ‘rediscovery’ of a hitherto unattributed fourteenth-century pulpitum screen. The stylistic context for the feature lies largely within the great architectural lodges of south-west England. There are strong grounds for suggesting that its designer was the innovative master, William Joy. If this attribution is correct, the commission is probably to be dated to the later 1320s, and no later than c 1330. The fact that the patrons for this prestigious work were the White Monks of Tintern serves only to underline its importance. From the surviving evidence, the construction of such an elaborate pulpitum within a British Cistercian context appears to have been an especially rare occurrence.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 78 , March 1998 , pp. 177 - 268
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1998

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Alexander, J. and Binski, P. (eds.) 1987. Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200–1400, London Google Scholar
Aubert, M. 1947. L'Architecture Cistercienne en France, 2nd edn., 2 vols., Paris Google Scholar
Baylis, P. 1902–1904. ‘Tintern Abbey’, Trans. Woolhope Natur. Fid. Club, 294–9Google Scholar
Biddle, M. 1993. ‘The shrine restored’, The Alban Lin., 39, 13–20 Google Scholar
Bilson, J. 1909. ‘The architecture of the Cistercians, with special reference to some of their earlier churches in England’, Archaeol. J., 66, 185–280 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Binski, P. 1995. Westminster Abbey and the Plantagenets: Kingship and the Representation of Power 1200–1400, New Haven Google Scholar
Bond, F. 1908. Screens and Galleries in English Churches, London Google Scholar
Bony, J. 1979. The English Decorated Style: Gothic Architecture Transformed 1250–1150, Oxford Google Scholar
Blashill, T. 1878. Guide to Tintern Abbey, Monmouth Google Scholar
Blashill, T. 1881–1882 ‘The architectural history of Tintern Abbey’, Trans. Bristol Gloucestershire Archaeol. Soc, 6, 88–106 Google Scholar
Blashill, T. 1886. ‘Tintern Abbey’, Archaeol. Cambrensi., 5th ser., 3, 241–52Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1901. ‘The architecture of Hayles Abbey’, Trans. Bristol Gloucestershire Archaeol So., 24, 126–35Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1905. Waverley Abbey, Surrey Archaeol. Soc, London Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1908. ‘Stanley Abbey’, Wiltshire Archaeol. Natur. Hist. Mag., 35, 541–81Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1919. Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire, 2nd edn., London Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1929. Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire, 2nd edn., revised, London Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. 1931. ‘A west country school of masons’, Archaeologi., 81, 1–18 Google Scholar
Brakspear, H. and Evans, M. 1910. Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire, 2nd edn., revised, London Google Scholar
Butler, L.A.S. 1976. Neath Abbey, Official Handbook, London Google Scholar
Caley, J., Ellis, H. and Bandinel, B. (eds.) 1817–1830. William Dugdale, Monasticon Anglicanum, V, 6 vols., London Google Scholar
Cocke, T. and Kidson, P. 1993. Salisbury Cathedral: Perspectives on the Architectural History, London Google Scholar
Coldstream, N. 1976. ‘English Decorated shrine bases’, J. Brit. Archaeol. Ass., 129, 15–34 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coldstream, N. 1986. ‘Cistercian architecture from Beaulieu to the Dissolution’, in Cistercian Art and Architecture in the British Isles (eds. Norton, C. and Park, D.), 139–59, Cambridge Google Scholar
Coldstream, N. 1987. ‘The kingdom of Heaven: its architectural setting’, in Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200–1400 (eds. Alexander, J. and Binski, P.), 92–7, London Google Scholar
Coldstream, N. 1994. The Decorated Style: Architecture and Ornament 1240–1360, London Google Scholar
Coppack, G. 1993. English Heritage Book of Fountains Abbey, London Google Scholar
Coppack, G. and Fergusson, P. 1994. Rievaulx Abbey, English Heritage Official Guide, London Google Scholar
Cowley, F.G. 1977. The Monastic Order in South Wales, 1066–1349, Cardiff Google Scholar
Coxe, W. 1801. An Historical Tour in Monmouthshire, 2 vols., London Google Scholar
Courtney, P. and Gray, M. 1991. ‘Tintern Abbey after the Dissolution’, Bull. Board Celtic Stud., 38, 145–58Google Scholar
Craster, O.E. 1956. Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire, London Google Scholar
Crouch, D. 1990. William Marshal: Court, Career and Chivalry in the Angevin Empire 1147–1219, London Google Scholar
Dickinson, J.C. 1961. Monastic Life in Medieval England, London Google Scholar
Dimier, M.A. 1982. L'Art Cistercien: France, 3rd edn., La Pierre-qui-Vire Google Scholar
Draper, P. 1981. ‘The sequence and dating of the Decorated work at Wells’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Wells and Glaston-bury (eds. Coldstream, N. and Draper, P.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 4, 18–29 Google Scholar
Draper, P. 1987. ‘Architecture and liturgy’, in Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200–1400 (eds. Alexander, J. and Binski, P.), 83–91, London Google Scholar
Erskine, A. (ed.) 1983. The Accounts of the Fabric of Exeter Cathedral, 1279–1353: Part II 1328–1353, Devon Cornwall Ree. Soc. Pubi., new ser., 26, 273–4Google Scholar
Evans, D.H. 1995. Valle Crucis Abbey, Cadw Official Guide, revised edn., Cardiff Google Scholar
Evans, W. and Worsley, R. 1981. Eglwys Gadeiriol Tyddewi - St Davids Cathedral 1181–1981, St Davids Google Scholar
Fergusson, P. 1984. Architecture of Solitude: Cistercian Abbeys in Twelfth-Century England, Princeton Google Scholar
Fergusson, P. 1990. Roche Abbey, English Heritage Official Guide, London Google Scholar
Fretton, W.G. 1872. ‘Memorials of the White-friars, Coventry’, Birmingham Midland Inst. Trans., 3, 63–78 Google Scholar
Gilpin, W. 1782. Observations on the River Wye, London Google Scholar
Gilyard-Beer, R. 1976. Abbeys: An Illustrated Guide to the Abbeys of England and Wales, 2nd edn., London Google Scholar
Girouard, M. 1983. Robert Smythson and the Elizabethan Country House, New Haven Google Scholar
Goodall, J. 1995. ‘A study of the grotesque 14th-century sculpture at Adderbury, Bloxham and Hanwell in its architectural context’, Oxoniensi., 60, 271–332 Google Scholar
Greening Lamborn, E.A. 1934. ‘The shrine of St Edburga’, Oxfordshire Archaeol. Soc. Rep., 80, 42–52 Google Scholar
Griffiths, R.A. 1984. ‘Medieval Severnside: The Welsh Connection’, in Welsh Society and Nationhood (eds. Davies, R.R., Griffiths, R.A., Jones, I.G. and Morgan, K.O.), 70–89, Cardiff Google Scholar
Grose, F. 1783–1797. The Antiquities of England and Wales, new edn., 8 vols., London Google Scholar
Harrison, S. 1997a. ‘The loose architectural detail’, in A Definitive History of Dore Abbey (eds. Shoesmith, R. and Richardson, R.), 63–76, Almeley Google Scholar
Harrison, S. 1997b. ‘A syncopated arcade from Keynsham Abbey’, in ‘Almost the Richest City’: Bristol in the Middle Ages (ed. Keen, L.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 19, 68–74 Google Scholar
Harvey, J. (ed.) 1969. William Worcestre: Itineraries, Oxford Google Scholar
Harvey, J. 1978. The Perpendicular Style 1330–1485, London Google Scholar
Harvey, J. 1984. English Mediaeval Architects: A Biographical Dictionary down to 1550, revised edn., Gloucester Google Scholar
Heath, C. 1793. Historical and Descriptive Accounts of the Ancient and Present State of Tintern Abbey, Monmouth Google Scholar
Hillaby, J. 1997. ‘The buried evidence: The Opus Dei’, in A Definitive History of Dore Abbey (eds. Shoesmith, R. and Richardson, R.), 37–44, Almeley Google Scholar
Hope, W.H., St, John 1900. ‘Fountains Abbey’, Yorkshire Archaeol. J., 15, 269–402 Google Scholar
Hope, W.H., St, John 1917. ‘Quire screens in English churches with special reference to the twelfth-century quire screen formerly in the cathedral church of Ely’, Archaeologia, 67, 43–110 Google Scholar
Hope, W.H., St, John and Bilson, J. 1907. Architectural Description of Kirkstall Abbey, Pubi. Thoresby Soc, 16 Google Scholar
Hope, W.H., St, John and Brakspear, H. 1911. ‘Jervaulx Abbey’, Yorkshire Archaeol. J., 21, 303–44Google Scholar
Janauschek, L. 1877. Originum Cisterciensium, Vienna Google Scholar
Jansen, V. 1991. ‘The design and building sequence of the eastern arm of Exeter Cathedral, c. 1270–1310: A qualified study’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Exeter Cathedral (ed. Kelly, F.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 11, 35–56, London Google Scholar
Johns, C.N. 1978. Caerphilly Castle, Official Handbook, Cardiff Google Scholar
Kenyon, J.R. 1994. Raglan Castle, Cadw Official Guide, revised edn., Cardiff Google Scholar
King, A.A. 1955. Liturgies of the Religious Orders, London Google Scholar
Knapp, U. 1997. Das Kloster Maulbronn: Geschichte und Baugeschihte, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Knowles, D. 1963. The Historian and Character and Other Essays, Cambridge Google Scholar
Legner, A. (ed.) 1978. Die Parler und der Schöne Stil 1350–1400, 1, Cologne Google Scholar
Lekai, L.J. 1953. The White Monks, Okauchee Google Scholar
Lekai, L.J. 1977. The Cistercians: Ideals and Reality, Ohio Google Scholar
Luard, H.R. (ed.) 1864–1869. Annales Monastici, Rolls Series, 36, II, London Google Scholar
Maclean, J. (ed.) 1883. The Berkeley Manuscripts: The Lives of the Berkeleys, Lords of the Honour, Castle and Manor of Berkeley, in the County of Gloucester, from 1066 to 1618 by John Smyth of Nibley, I, Gloucester Google Scholar
Marks, R. 1993. Stained Glass in England during the Middle Ages, London Google Scholar
McAleer, J.P. 1991. ‘The problem(s) of the St Edmund's Chapel, Exeter Cathedral’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Exeter Cathedral (ed. Kelly, F.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 11, 147–61, London Google Scholar
Monckton, L.A. 1997. ‘The myth of William Canynges and the late medieval rebuilding of St Mary Redcliffe’, in ‘Almost the Richest City’: Bristol in the Middle Ages (ed. Keen, L.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 19, 57–67, London Google Scholar
Morris, R. 1979. Cathedrals and Abbeys of England and Wales: The Building Church, 600–1540, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1973. ‘The local influence of 'Hereford Cathedral in the Decorated period’, Trans. Woolhope Natur. Fid. Clu., 41/1, 48–67 Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1974. ‘The mason of Madley, Allensmore and Eaton Bishop’, Trans. Woolhope Natur. Fid. Clu., 41/2, 180–97Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1978. ‘The development of later gothic mouldings in England c. 1250–1400, Part I’, Architect. Hist., 21, 18–57 Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1979. ‘The development of later Gothic mouldings in England c. 1250–1400, Part II’, Architect. Hist., 22, 1–48 Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1985. ‘Ballflower work in Gloucester and its vicinity’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Gloucester and Tewkesbury (eds. Heslop, T.A. and Sekules, V.A.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 7, 99–115, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1990a. ‘The Gothic mouldings of the Latin and Lady Chapels’, in Saint Frideswide's Monastery at Oxford: Archaeological and Architectural Studies (ed. Blair, J.), 169–83, Gloucester Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1990b. ‘The new work at old St Paul's Cathedral and its place in English thirteenth-century architecture’, in Medieval Art, Architecture and Archaeology in London (ed. Grant, L.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 10, 74–100, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1991. ‘Thomas of Witney at Exeter, Winchester and Wells’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Exeter Cathedral (ed. Kelly, F.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 11, 57–84, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1996. ‘The style and buttressing of Salisbury Cathedral tower’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Salisbury Cathedral (eds. Keen, L. and Cocke, T.), Brit Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 17, 46–58, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. 1997. ‘European prodigy or regional eccentric?: The rebuilding of St Augustine's Abbey Church, Bristol’, in ‘Almost the Richest City’: Bristol in the Middle Ages (ed. Keen, L.), Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 19, 41–56, London Google Scholar
Morris, R.K. and Monckton, L.A. forthcoming. ‘Sherborne Abbey excavations: Gothic architecture and worked stones’, in Sherborne Abbey Excavations 1972–1976 (eds. Keen, L. and Ellis, P.)Google Scholar
Neale, J. 1877. The Abbey Church of St Alban, Hertfordshire, London Google Scholar
Newman, J. 1995. The Buildings of Wales: Glamorgan, London Google Scholar
Norton, C. 1986. ‘Table of Cistercian legislation on art and architecture’, in Cistercian Art and Architecture in the British Isles (eds. Norton, C. and Park, D.), 315–93, Cambridge Google Scholar
[Paul, R.]. 1898. ‘Tintern Abbey’, The Builde., 75, 9–11 Google Scholar
Peers, C.R. 1922. ‘Tintern Abbey’, Trans. Bristol Gloucsestershire Archaeol. So., 44, 8–11 Google Scholar
Perks, J.C. 1946–1948. ‘The architectural history of Chepstow Castle during the Middle Ages’, Trans. Bristol Gloucestershire Archaeol. Soc, 67, 307–46Google Scholar
Potter, J. 1847. Remains of Ancient Monastic Architecture in England: Represented in a Series of Views, Plans, Elevations, Sections and Details, Tintern Plates: I–XLVI, London Google Scholar
Prestwich, M. 1988. Edward I, London Google Scholar
RCAHMS. 1956. An Inventory of the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Roxburghshire, II, Roy. Comm. Ancient Hist. Monuments Scotland, Edinburgh Google Scholar
Renn, D. 1997. Caerphilly Castle, Cadw Official Guide, revised edn., Cardiff Google Scholar
Robinson, D.M. 1995. Tintern Abbey, Cadw Official Guide, 3rd edn., Cardiff Google Scholar
Robinson, D.M. 1996. ‘The twelfth-century church at Tintern Abbey’, Monmouthshire Antiq., 12, 35–9Google Scholar
Robinson, D.M. 1997a. ‘The making of a monument: die Office of Woods and its successors at Tintern Abbey’, Monmouthshire Antiq., 13, 43–56 Google Scholar
Robinson, D.M. 1997b. Neath Abbey, Cadw Pamphlet Guide, 3rd edn., Cardiff Google Scholar
Robinson, D.M. and Platt, C. 1992. Strata Florida Abbey – Talley Abbey, Cadw Official Guide, Cardiff Google Scholar
Sekules, V. 1991. ‘The liturgical furnishings of the choir of Exeter cathedral’, in Medieval Art and Architecture at Exeter Cathedral (ed. Kelly, F.) Brit. Archaeol. Ass. Conference Trans., 11, 172–9, London Google Scholar
Sharpe, E. 1848. Architectural Parallels, London Google Scholar
Stratford, N. 1991. ‘Bishop Grandisson and the visual arts’, in Exeter Cathedral: A Celebration (ed. Swanton, M.), 144–55, Exeter Google Scholar
Taylor, J. 1869. Tintern Abbey and its Founders, Bristol Google Scholar
Thurlby, M. 1995. ‘Glastonbury Abbey Lady Chapel’, Antiq. J., 75, 107–70.Google Scholar
Thurley, S. 1993. The Royal Palaces of Tudor England: Architecture and Court Life 1460–1547, New Haven Google Scholar
Vallance, A. 1947. Greater English Church Screens, London Google Scholar
Williams, D.H. 1976. White Monks in Gwent and the Border, Pontypool Google Scholar
Williams, D.H. 1970–1978. ‘Sale of goods at Abbey Dore’, Monmouthshire Antiq., 3, 192–4Google Scholar
Williams, D.H. 1984. The Welsh Cistercians, 2nd edn., 2 vols., Caldey Island Google Scholar
Williams, G. 1981. ‘Henry de Gower (1278–1347): Bishop and builder’, Archaeol. Cambrensis, 130, 1–18 Google Scholar
Wilson, C. 1980. ‘The origins of the Perpendicular style and its development to circa 1360’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of London Google Scholar
Wilson, C. 1987. ‘The English response to French Gothic architecture, c. 1200–1350’, in Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200–1400 (eds. Alexander, J. and Binski, P.), 74–82, London Google Scholar
Wilson, C. 1990. The Gothic Cathedral: The Architecture of the Great Church 1130–1530, London Google Scholar
Wilson, C. 1995. ‘The medieval monuments’, in A History of Canterbury Cathedral (eds. Collinson, P., et al.), 451–510, Oxford Google Scholar
Wood, J.G. 1908–1909. ‘Tintern Abbey’, Archaeol. Cambrensis, 6th ser., 8, 345–58; 9, 49–64 Google Scholar
Wood, J.G. 1912. On Some Recent Features of the Monastic Buildings Disclosed by Recent Excavations with the Precincts of Tintern Abbey, Monmouthshire and Caerleon Anita. Ass. Google Scholar
Woodfield, C. 1971. ‘The Whitefriars, Coventry’, Archaeol. J., 128, 251, fig. 11Google Scholar