'The narrative of the Great Patriotic War is a part of Russian national identity, but Western studies show that most of the Soviet population welcomed the German invasion as a liberation from Stalinist repression. Focusing on the less-studied northwestern region of the Soviet Union - the area between Leningrad and Moscow - Enstad uses Soviet and German sources to understand how Soviet society experienced the German invasion and occupation. … The Russian population came to see the Nazi occupiers as no better than the Bolsheviks. Enstad's conclusion that decades of Soviet rule had not formed bonds of loyalty between the people and the regime is not surprising, but it is a valuable confirmation that a lack of 'patriotism' was evident among the Russian population as well as among other peoples of the Soviet Union. A valuable resource for those interested in German-occupied Soviet Union. … Recommended.'
R. P. Peters
Source: Choice
'This is a superb monograph with important implications for our understanding of both life under Stalinism and responses to Nazi conquest among ethnically Russian peasants. It opens an intriguing window on the experiences of one hitherto understudied region of Russia during the war, and constitutes an inspiring model for the study of public attitudes and private emotions in other parts of the Soviet Union in this era.'
Aviel Roshwald
Source: Slavic Review
‘… a welcome addition to the literature on the Soviet experience of World War II. Scholars studying World War II or the history of Soviet rural life will find that it adds a complementary view to works on the occupation of other areas of the Soviet Union.’
Seth Bernstein
Source: Journal of Contemporary History
'… Enstad’s work deserves acclaim not just for its insights into the Soviet Russian bifurcation during the war, but also as a model microhistory with an approach well worth emulating.’
Kiril Feferman
Source: The Russian Review
'… offers rich food for thought and prompts further inquiries …'
Natalia Kovalyova
Source: Europe-Asia Studies
‘The book’s findings offer valuable insight into life within the wartime USSR, and demonstrate the Stalinist system’s prewar failure to create meaningful bonds of loyalty between the regime and the majority of the Soviet population. Enstad’s work helps to fill a gap in existing Soviet historiography, which has long overlooked the experiences of Soviet citizens who fell under German occupation during World War II … this book will be much appreciated by anyone interested in Soviet experiences of World War II as well as anyone interested in better understanding how tens of millions of Soviet citizens - particularly rural residents and collective farmers - felt about the Soviet state in the 1940s.’
Maris Rowe-McCulloch
Source: H-Russia
‘This is an excellent book, a model of historical research, clearly written, and interesting and provocative to boot. I strongly recommend it to anybody interested in the history of either the Soviet Union or the Second World War.’
Paul Robinson
Source: Irrussianality