Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Figures and Tables
- Acknowledgements of Original Publishers
- Personal Acknowledgements
- Contributors
- Dedication
- Editor’s Introduction
- 1 Ashes and Diamonds
- 2 The Roots of the Western
- 3 Pickup on South Street
- 4 Extract from Underworld U.S.A.
- 5 Politicising Scottish Film Culture
- 6 Crossfire and the Anglo-American Critical Tradition
- 7 Breaking the Signs: Scotch Myths as Cultural Struggle
- 8 Scotland and Cinema: The Iniquity of the Fathers
- 9 The Maggie
- 10 National Identities
- 11 TV Commercials: Moving Statues and Old Movies
- 12 Tele-history: The Dragon Has Two Tongues
- 13 Scotland’s Story
- 14 The Dialectic of National Identity: The Glasgow Empire Exhibition of 1938
- 15 The New Scottish Cinema?
- 16 The Rises and Falls of the Edinburgh International Film Festival
- 17 A Dram for All Seasons: The Diverse Identities of Scotch
- 18 Scottish Culture: A Reply to David McCrone
- 19 In Praise of a Poor Cinema
- 20 Wake for a Glasgow Culture Hero
- 21 The Cultural Necessity of a Poor Celtic Cinema
- 22 Culloden: A Pre-emptive Strike
- 23 Casablanca: Where Have All the Fascists Gone?
- 24 The Scottish Discursive Unconscious
- 25 Chinese Boxes and Russian Dolls: Tracking the Elusive Cinematic City
- 26 Artists and Philistines: The Irish and Scottish Film Milieux
- 27 Braveheart and the Scottish Aesthetic Dementia
- 28 The Exquisite Corpse of Rab(elais) C(opernicus) Nesbitt
- 29 Mise-en-scène Degree Zero: Jean-Pierre Melville’s Le Samouraï
- 30 The Critics Who Knew Too Little: Hitchcock and the Absent Class Paradigm
- 31 Caledonianising Macbeth, or, How Scottish is ‘The Scottish Play’?
- 32 Two Steps Forward, One Step Back: Cultural Struggle in the British Film Institute
- 33 Transatlantic Scots, Their Interlocutors and the Scottish Discursive Unconscious
- 34 Scotch Myths, Scottish Film Culture and the Suppression of Ludic Modernism
- 35 Bring Furrit the Tartan-Necks! Nationalist Intellectuals and Scottish Popular Culture
- 36 Vanished or Banished? Murray Grigor as Absent Scots Auteur
- Author’s Afterword
- Select Bibliography
- Indexes
34 - Scotch Myths, Scottish Film Culture and the Suppression of Ludic Modernism
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 March 2025
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Figures and Tables
- Acknowledgements of Original Publishers
- Personal Acknowledgements
- Contributors
- Dedication
- Editor’s Introduction
- 1 Ashes and Diamonds
- 2 The Roots of the Western
- 3 Pickup on South Street
- 4 Extract from Underworld U.S.A.
- 5 Politicising Scottish Film Culture
- 6 Crossfire and the Anglo-American Critical Tradition
- 7 Breaking the Signs: Scotch Myths as Cultural Struggle
- 8 Scotland and Cinema: The Iniquity of the Fathers
- 9 The Maggie
- 10 National Identities
- 11 TV Commercials: Moving Statues and Old Movies
- 12 Tele-history: The Dragon Has Two Tongues
- 13 Scotland’s Story
- 14 The Dialectic of National Identity: The Glasgow Empire Exhibition of 1938
- 15 The New Scottish Cinema?
- 16 The Rises and Falls of the Edinburgh International Film Festival
- 17 A Dram for All Seasons: The Diverse Identities of Scotch
- 18 Scottish Culture: A Reply to David McCrone
- 19 In Praise of a Poor Cinema
- 20 Wake for a Glasgow Culture Hero
- 21 The Cultural Necessity of a Poor Celtic Cinema
- 22 Culloden: A Pre-emptive Strike
- 23 Casablanca: Where Have All the Fascists Gone?
- 24 The Scottish Discursive Unconscious
- 25 Chinese Boxes and Russian Dolls: Tracking the Elusive Cinematic City
- 26 Artists and Philistines: The Irish and Scottish Film Milieux
- 27 Braveheart and the Scottish Aesthetic Dementia
- 28 The Exquisite Corpse of Rab(elais) C(opernicus) Nesbitt
- 29 Mise-en-scène Degree Zero: Jean-Pierre Melville’s Le Samouraï
- 30 The Critics Who Knew Too Little: Hitchcock and the Absent Class Paradigm
- 31 Caledonianising Macbeth, or, How Scottish is ‘The Scottish Play’?
- 32 Two Steps Forward, One Step Back: Cultural Struggle in the British Film Institute
- 33 Transatlantic Scots, Their Interlocutors and the Scottish Discursive Unconscious
- 34 Scotch Myths, Scottish Film Culture and the Suppression of Ludic Modernism
- 35 Bring Furrit the Tartan-Necks! Nationalist Intellectuals and Scottish Popular Culture
- 36 Vanished or Banished? Murray Grigor as Absent Scots Auteur
- Author’s Afterword
- Select Bibliography
- Indexes
Summary
Scottish moving image culture has produced three masterpieces of ludic modernism: John McGrath (1935–2002) and John Mackenzie (1928– 2011)'s The Cheviot, the Stag and the Black, Black Oil (1974), Ian Pattison and Colin Gilbert's BBC Television series Rab C. Nesbitt (1988–2014) and Murray Grigor's Scotch Myths (1982), funded by Channel 4. Having celebrated the two former, I now wish to remedy the scandalous lack of critical attention accorded to the latter. That lack is itself symptomatic of the effective suppression of Scotch Myths and of modernism (ludic or otherwise) within Scottish film culture. Indeed, to address Scotch Myths is to wade knee-deep into the debates which traversed Scottish film culture in the 1970s and 1980s. Yet until now a film constituting one of the key reference points in these debates has had no adequate description, far less analysis, of its subject matter and style. But first, what is meant by ‘ludic modernism’? The phrase recalls, and perhaps lies silently within, the increasingly prevalent concept of ludic postmodernism. The assertion underlying the latter is that once there was this monolithic phenomenon, modernism, which was austere, all-embracing, elitist, lacking the common touch and, above all, humourless. Ludic postmodernism, the argument runs, has swept all this away. Unable to say anything useful about the real world – if indeed, as postmodernism has it, the latter even exists at all – postmodern discourse has recourse only to the complex glissandi of its own operations. The only appropriate stance is one of ludic irony. We may be going to hell in a handcart, but let's have fun on the way! (Ludic) postmodernism, unaware of the structuralist binarism of its own position, sets itself in opposition to its self-projected grim-faced predecessor, modernism, and in the process travesties the latter. Justus Nieland, in his editorial introduction (appropriately entitled ‘Modernism's Laughter’) to a 2006 issue of Modernist Cultures, writes:
This special issue […] is animated by two claims. First, that modernism is funny, and the moderns [are] inveterate laughers, gigglers, joke-pullers and devastating wags. Second, that modernism's ubiquitous laughter is overlooked, undertheorised, and downright gagged by the aura of high seriousness that still infuses critical descriptions of modernism.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Cinema, Culture, ScotlandSelected Essays, pp. 469 - 486Publisher: Edinburgh University PressPrint publication year: 2024