Inappropriate diagnosis and treatment of urinary tract infections (UTIs) contribute to antibiotic overuse. The Inappropriate Diagnosis of UTI (ID-UTI) measure uses a standard definition of asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) and was validated in large hospitals. Critical access hospitals (CAHs) have different resources which may make ASB stewardship challenging. To address this inequity, we adapted the ID-UTI metric for use in CAHs and assessed the adapted measure’s feasibility, validity, and reliability.

Retrospective observational study

10 CAHs

From October 2022 to July 2023, CAHs submitted clinical information for adults admitted or discharged from the emergency department who received antibiotics for a positive urine culture. Feasibility of case submission was assessed as the number of CAHs achieving the goal of 59 cases. Validity (sensitivity/specificity) and reliability of the ID-UTI definition were assessed by dual-physician review of a random sample of submitted cases.

Among 10 CAHs able to participate throughout the study period, only 40% (4/10) submitted >59 cases (goal); an additional 3 submitted >35 cases (secondary goal). Per the ID-UTI metric, 28% (16/58) of cases were ASB. Compared to physician review, the ID-UTI metric had 100% specificity (ie all cases called ASB were ASB on clinical review) but poor sensitivity (48.5%; ie did not identify all ASB cases). Measure reliability was high (93% [54/58] agreement).

Similar to measure performance in non-CAHs, the ID-UTI measure had high reliability and specificity—all cases identified as ASB were considered ASB—but poor sensitivity. Though feasible for a subset of CAHs, barriers remain.

Asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) treatment is a common form of antibiotic overuse and diagnostic error. Antibiotic stewardship using the inappropriate diagnosis of urinary tract infection (ID-UTI) measure has reduced ASB treatment in diverse hospitals. However, critical access hospitals (CAHs) have differing resources that could impede stewardship. We aimed to determine if stewardship including the ID-UTI measure could reduce ASB treatment in CAHs.

From October 2022 to July 2023, ten CAHs participated in an Intensive Quality Improvement Cohort (IQIC) program including 3 interventions to reduce ASB treatment: 1) learning labs (ie, didactics with shared learning), 2) mentoring, and 3) data-driven performance reports including hospital peer comparison based on the ID-UTI measure. To assess effectiveness of the IQIC program, change in the ID-UTI measure (ie, percentage of patients treated for a UTI who had ASB) was compared to two non-equivalent control outcomes (antibiotic duration and unjustified fluoroquinolone use).

Ten CAHs abstracted a total of 608 positive urine culture cases. Over the cohort period, the percentage of patients treated for a UTI who had ASB declined (aOR per month = 0.935, 95% CI: 0.873, 1.001, P = 0.055) from 28.4% (range across hospitals, 0%-63%) in the first to 18.6% (range, 0%-33%) in the final month. In contrast, antibiotic duration and unjustified fluoroquinolone use were unchanged (P = 0.768 and 0.567, respectively).

The IQIC intervention, including learning labs, mentoring, and performance reports using the ID-UTI measure, was associated with a non-significant decrease in treatment of ASB, while control outcomes (duration and unjustified fluoroquinolone use) did not change.