Let
$p$ be a prime number and let
$F$ be a field of characteristic different from
$p$. We prove that there exist a field extension
$L/F$ and
$a,b,c,d$ in
$L^{\times }$ such that
$(a,b)=(b,c)=(c,d)=0$ in
$\mathrm {Br}(L)[p]$ but the mod p Massey product
$\langle a,b,c,d\rangle$ is not defined over
$L$. Thus, the strong Massey vanishing conjecture at the prime
$p$ fails for
$L$, and the cochain differential graded ring
$C^{* }(\Gamma _L,\mathbb Z/p\mathbb Z)$ of the absolute Galois group
$\Gamma _L$ of
$L$ is not formal. This answers a question of Positselski. As our main tool, we define a secondary obstruction that detects non-triviality of unramified torsors under tori, and which is of independent interest.