Let Fn be the free group on
$n \geq 2$ generators. We show that for all
$1 \leq m \leq 2n-3$ (respectively, for all
$1 \leq m \leq 2n-4$), there exists a subgroup of
${\operatorname{Aut}(F_n)}$ (respectively,
${\operatorname{Out}(F_n)}$), which has finiteness of type Fm but not of type
$FP_{m+1}(\mathbb{Q})$; hence, it is not m-coherent. In both cases, the new result is the upper bound
$m= 2n-3$ (respectively,
$m = 2n-4$), as it cannot be obtained by embedding direct products of free noncyclic groups, and certifies higher incoherence up to the virtual cohomological dimension and is therefore sharp. As a tool of the proof, we discuss the existence and nature of multiple inequivalent extensions of a suitable finite-index subgroup K4 of
${\operatorname{Aut}(F_2)}$ (isomorphic to the quotient of the pure braid group on four strands by its centre): the fibre of four of these extensions arise from the strand-forgetting maps on the braid groups, while a fifth is related with the Cardano–Ferrari epimorphism.