We consider finite simple graphs. Given a graph H and a positive integer
$n,$ the Turán number of H for the order
$n,$ denoted
$\mathrm {ex}(n,H),$ is the maximum size of a graph of order n not containing H as a subgraph. Erdős asked: ‘For which graphs H is it true that every graph on n vertices and
$\mathrm {ex}(n,H)+1$ edges contains at least two H’s? Perhaps this is always true.’ We solve this problem in the negative by proving that for every integer
$k\ge 4$ there exists a graph H of order k and at least two orders n such that there exists a graph of order n and size
$\mathrm {ex}(n,H)+1$ which contains exactly one copy of
$H.$ Denote by
$C_4$ the
$4$-cycle. We also prove that for every integer n with
$6\le n\le 11$ there exists a graph of order n and size
$\mathrm {ex}(n,C_4)+1$ which contains exactly one copy of
$C_4,$ but, for
$n=12$ or
$n=13,$ the minimum number of copies of
$C_4$ in a graph of order n and size
$\mathrm {ex}(n,C_4)+1$ is two.