Reproductive synchrony is common in populations that inhabit seasonal environments where reproductive timing is important to offspring survival. Weddell seals (Leptonychotes weddellii) reproduce in strongly seasonal Antarctic environments and are known to exhibit reproductive synchrony that varies by latitude, whereby more southerly populations give birth later. The Erebus Bay population of Weddell seals is the southernmost mammal population in the world, and birth-date synchrony has been demonstrated in this population. Various life history correlates including sex, maternal age and reproductive status have been identified as predictors of birth timing, but all prior work has been done on pups born to locally born mothers. Immigrant females originating from unknown sites in more northerly locations also produce pups in Erebus Bay and may have different birth timing due to the earlier average birth dates in their natal colonies. Using 22 years of capture-mark-recapture data for Weddell seals in Erebus Bay, we aimed to assess whether the timing of birth dates for pups born to immigrant mothers differs from that of pups born to locally born mothers. To our knowledge, this is the first time that such a comparison has been studied in a wild population. Birth dates were examined using Bayesian linear regression. We analysed birth dates from 7539 pups (4932 from locally born mothers, 2607 from immigrant mothers) born to 2210 mothers (1254 locally born, 956 immigrant) and found that there were no biologically impactful differences in the birth dates of pups born to locally born or immigrant mothers. Additionally, birth-date patterns for immigrant mothers were similar to those for locally born mothers with respect to various traits. Our results demonstrate that immigrant Weddell seal mothers can synchronize birth timing with locally born mothers. More research is required to understand the underlying mechanisms that allow for immigrant seals to achieve birth-date synchrony.