1. Introduction
The Antarctic Ice Sheet (AIS) is the Earth’s largest freshwater reservoir, containing an ice mass equivalent to a global sea-level rise of 58 m (Fretwell and others, Reference Fretwell2013). The AIS is losing mass due to the increasing global surface temperature, contributing to a rise in sea level (The IMBIE team, 2018), which can cause direct and indirect global social and economic damage from coastal flooding (Kirezci and others, Reference Kirezci2020; Dietz and Koninx, Reference Dietz and Koninx2022). Furthermore, a massive freshwater input into the Southern Ocean from the AIS melting may reduce the formation of the Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW), which might weaken the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation that affects global climate (Swingedouw and others, Reference Swingedouw2008; Silvano and others, Reference Silvano2018; Chen and others, Reference Chen2023; Li and others, Reference Li, DeConto, Pollard and Hu2024).
Although the mass balance of the AIS is controlled by complex interactions and feedback between the ice sheet, ocean, atmosphere, and solid earth (Fyke and others, Reference Fyke, Sergienko, Löfverström, Price and Lenaerts2018), the surface mass balance (SMB), the difference between snowfall and losses caused by evaporation, sublimation, meltwater runoff, and wind erosion, is one of the main factors controlling the total mass balance of the AIS (Mottram and others, Reference Mottram2021). Therefore, reliable estimates of the SMB are essential for predicting the changes in the total mass of the AIS in response to climate change. Recent advances in satellite remote sensing techniques, combined with regional climate models and glacial isostatic adjustment, have allowed characterization of the present-day SMB of the AIS, providing insights into future sea-level rise under global warming (Shepherd and others, Reference Shepherd2012; The IMBIE team, 2018; Velicogna and others, Reference Velicogna2020; Mottram and others, Reference Mottram2021). Although these studies show that the AIS has been losing mass in recent decades under the impacts of global warming, the continent-wide SMB changes remain difficult to quantify because the SMB varies considerably across wide scales of space and time because of complex interactions between atmosphere, snow–ice surface, large-scale atmospheric circulation and ocean conditions, and ice sheet topography (Lenaerts and others, Reference Lenaerts, Medley, van den Broeke and Wouters2019; Dalaiden and others, Reference Dalaiden, Goosse, Lenaerts, Cavitte and Henderson2020; Wang and others, Reference Wang2020; Mottram and others, Reference Mottram2021). The long-term spatiotemporal records of the SMB beyond the instrumental period are of critical importance for understanding the fundamental processes and key drivers controlling spatial patterns and temporal variability in the AIS SMB and making better projections of the AIS response to future climate changes (King and Watson, Reference King and Watson2020).
Antarctic ice cores provide valuable information on the spatial and temporal patterns of the AIS SMB on different time scales at an annual resolution in terms of the net rate of mass gain at the surface of the AIS using the snow accumulation rate (SAR). Thus far, the comprehensive decadal to millennial-scale SAR changes on the regional scale have been extracted from existing Antarctic ice core records (e.g., Altnau and others, Reference Altnau, Schlosser, Isaksson and Divine2015; Thomas and others, Reference Thomas2017; Medley and Thomas, Reference Medley and Thomas2019; Wang and others, Reference Wang2019; Ekaykin and others, Reference Ekaykin, Veres and Wang2024). A comprehensive compilation of the SAR for the total AIS suggests that a progressively increasing trend was observed from the early 19th century to the late-20th century, which may have partially offset sea-level rise, particularly by mitigating ∼10 mm of the rise that would have otherwise occurred during the 20th century (Thomas and others, Reference Thomas2017; Medley and Thomas, Reference Medley and Thomas2019). Nevertheless, these composite records revealed a complex pattern of spatial and temporal variability in SAR on the regional scales. For example, the SAR trends of the western West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) were positive for 1800–1900 CE (Common Era), but negative for 1900–2010 CE, while opposite trends occurred in the eastern WAIS and at the Antarctic Peninsula (Medley and Thomas, Reference Medley and Thomas2019; Wang and others, Reference Wang2019). On the other hand, the SAR averaged over East Antarctica except for the Wilkes Land coast (70–150°E) exhibit an increasing trend since 1800 CE, with a potentially accelerating increase over the 20th century as the climate has warmed (Altnau and others, Reference Altnau, Schlosser, Isaksson and Divine2015; Thomas and others, Reference Thomas2017; Medley and Thomas, Reference Medley and Thomas2019; Ekaykin and others, Reference Ekaykin, Veres and Wang2024). By contrast, the SAR variability in Victoria Land (150–170°E), East Antarctica, showed a negative trend during the second half of the 20th century (Thomas and others, Reference Thomas2017).
Although the number of ice core SMB records has increased in recent years, the long-term, spatially continuous high-resolution datasets of the SMB are still limited, making it difficult to characterize the AIS SMB variability and its response to the changes in atmospheric and oceanic forcings in the long-term compared to a short-term (Thomas and others, Reference Thomas2017). The Victoria Land coast of East Antarctica is one of the data-poor areas of geographical importance because this area is bounded by the Ross Sea, which contributes 20‒40% of the total AABW production (Johnson, Reference Johnson2008; Meredith, Reference Meredith2013). Observations have shown that multi-decadal freshening has occurred in Ross Sea bottom water because of climate warming and increased glacial meltwater inflow, reducing the formation and export of dense shelf water in the Ross Sea (Jacobs and others, Reference Jacobs, Giulivi and Mele2002; Menezes and others, Reference Menezes, Macdonald and Schatzman2017; Gunn and others, Reference Gunn, Rintoul, England and Bowen2023). Despite its importance, very few ice core records of centennial to millennial-scale SAR variability are available from this area (Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2002; Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019; Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021), limiting the understanding of fundamental processes that control the glacier mass balance, which is essential for accurately predicting the variability of AABW production in the Ross Sea in response to accelerated global warming. This highlights the need for new reconstructions of the long-term SAR records from ice cores in the Victoria Land coastal region.
To characterize SAR variations from ice cores, it is crucial to establish an accurate and precise depth-age relationship for the core, enabling the subsequent reconstruction of past SAR variability. Dating of the core is determined primarily by counting the annual layers identified by the well-defined seasonal variations in stable water isotopic compositions and glaciochemical impurities (Dansgaard, Reference Dansgaard1964; Legrand and Mayewski, Reference Legrand and Mayewski1997; Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup, Svensson, Rasmussen, Winther, Steig and Axelrod2012). However, dating becomes more complicated with depth due to progressive thinning and diffusion of annual layers. To address this, various methods have been employed to constrain the chronology of deeper ice core sections: (i) glaciological modeling including ice flow, firn densification, and accumulation rate models, (ii) identification of stratigraphic reference horizons such as radioactive fallout from atmospheric nuclear weapon tests and sulfate or tephra deposits from large volcanic eruptions, (iii) synchronization of ice and gas stratigraphy between different ice cores, and (iv) wiggle-matching of the ice core records to insolation time series or other dated paleo-archives (Lemieux-Dudon and others, Reference Lemieux-Dudon2010; Klauenberg and others, Reference Klauenberg, Blakwell, Buck, Mulvaney, Rothlisberger and Wolff2011; Abbott and Davies, Reference Abbott and Davies2012; Sigl and others, Reference Sigl2015; Arienzo and others, Reference Arienzo2016; Hwang and others, Reference Hwang, Hur, Lee, Han, Hong and Motoyama2019; Verjans and others, Reference Verjans2020).
In this study, we present a detailed chronology for the uppermost 98.5 m of a 210.5 m deep ice core drilled on the Styx Glacier plateau (SGP) in northern Victoria Land, East Antarctica, providing ultimately decadal- to centennial-scale variability of the SAR in the western Ross Sea coast region. Building upon the previously established chronology for the top 9.89 m (Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel2024), we extended the dating using annual layer counting based on seasonal variations in the ionic and isotopic composition. The resulting age scale was further constrained by absolute age-depth tie-points, including volcanic markers and 239Pu fallout peaks, resulting in a well-constrained chronology from 1259 to 2014 CE, with a maximum dating uncertainty of ± 8 years. This chronology provided the basis for reconstructing SAR variability at the SGP over the past 755 years, revealing a long-term increasing trend overlain by inter- to multi-decadal fluctuations.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Study site and ice core drilling
The ice core site is located on the SGP (73° 51.10′S; 163° 41.22′E; 1,623 m above sea level, a.s.l.), a 150 km2 area situated along the western Ross Sea margin of the Transantarctic Mountains (TAM), ∼60 km inland from the Ross Sea coast, and ∼85 km away from the Korean Jang Bogo Antarctic Research Station in northern Victoria Land, East Antarctica (Figure 1). The SGP lies within a glaciated saddle area flanked by rugged TAM peaks, where ice flows southeastward through a valley outlet toward the Ross Sea. This region is characterized by prevailing southerly/southwesterly katabatic winds descending from the elevated TAM slopes (Udisti and others, Reference Udisti, Becagli, Castellano, Traversi, Vermigli and Piccardi1999), with air masses originating from the Ross Sea (Sinclair and others, Reference Sinclair, Bertler and Trompetter2010; Markle and others, Reference Markle, Bertler, Sinclair and Sneed2012; Ro and others, Reference Ro2022). Despite the dominance of katabatic winds in northern Victoria Land, the snow layers of the SGP are well-preserved due to the absence of summer melt (Udisti and others, Reference Udisti, Traversi, Becagli and Piccardi1998, Reference Udisti, Becagli, Castellano, Traversi, Vermigli and Piccardi1999; Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel, Hong, Han, Kim, Lee and Hur2021) and the reduced influence of katabatic winds because the SGP is sheltered by surrounding topography (Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2000). The annual SARs are relatively high, ranging from 130 to 226 mm in water equivalent (w.e.) per year (Udisti, Reference Udisti1996; Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2000; Han and others, Reference Han2015; Kwak and others, Reference Kwak2015; Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel, Han, Kim, Hong, Lee and Hur2020, Reference Nyamgerel, Hong, Han, Kim, Lee and Hur2021, Reference Nyamgerel2024; Ro and others, Reference Ro2022), making the SGP an ideal location for preserving high-resolution glaciochemical records. The mean annual temperature is −32.5°C, with a horizontal ice flow velocity of 0.9–2.3 m yr−1 and an estimated ice thickness of 550 m (Han and others, Reference Han2015; Yang and others, Reference Yang2018; Kim and others, Reference Kim, Prior, Han, Qi, Han and Ju2020).

Figure 1. (A) Map of the Antarctic continent showing the locations of the Styx-M and Roosevelt Island Climate Evolution (RICE) ice cores from the Styx Glacier plateau (SGP) (163° 41.22′E, 73° 51.10′S, 1,623 m a.s.l.) and Roosevelt Island (161° 42.36′W, 79° 21.84′S, 550 m a.s.l.), respectively. (b) Enlarged scale of the western Ross Sea region showing the SGP, the Korean Jang Bogo Station (164° 13.7′E, 74° 37.4′S, 36 m a.s.l.), and various ice core sites: Hercules Névé (HN; 165° 24′E, 73° 6′S, 2,960 m a.s.l.), Talos Dome (TD; 158° 45′E, 72° 22′S, 2,316 m a.s.l.), and GV7 (158° 51.14′E, 70° 41.05′S, 1,947 m a.s.l.). Maps were modified from images generated in software QGIS 3.24.2 (https://www.qgis.org) using a visualization platform Quantarctica (Matsuoka and others, Reference Matsuoka2021).
The drilling operation was conducted from 12 December 2014 to 1 January 2015 as part of ice core drilling program of Korea Polar Research Institute (KOPRI) in Antarctica. A 210.5 m-long ice core, hereafter referred to as the Styx-M core, was recovered in 300 runs using a shallow ice coring system (Geotech Co. Ltd., Japan), with section lengths ranging from 19 cm to 100 cm (70 cm on average). Each section was weighed in the field to determine its bulk density, providing the density profile of the ice core as a function of depth. The ice core samples were sealed in polyethylene bags, transported frozen to KOPRI, and stored at −15°C in a cold room until further analysis. Additional details on the study site and drilling operations are reported elsewhere (Han and others, Reference Han2015; Yang and others, Reference Yang2018; Jang and others, Reference Jang2019; Kim and others, Reference Kim, Prior, Han, Qi, Han and Ju2020; Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel2024).
2.2. Analytical method
This study focused on the top 98.5 m of the Styx-M core, for which high-resolution glaciochemical and isotopic analyses has been completed. Measurements included liquid conductivity and insoluble particle concentrations using a continuous ice core melting system, major ions (Na+, Ca2+, and SO42–) using a two-channel ion chromatography (IC) system, and stable oxygen isotope ratios (δ18O) of meltwater using cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS). All samples were decontaminated following the procedures described below, except for δ18O subsamples, cut parallel to the core axis without additional decontamination. Sampling resolution varied depending on the analytical procedures, as detailed in the following sections.
2.2.1 Decontamination procedure
The top 12.2 m of the core was composed of low-density (d < ∼ 0.55 g cm–3) firn, which was too fragile to be processed using the continuous melting system (see section 2.2.2). Hence, this section was manually cut into 8.3 cm to 45 cm long sticks (3.2 × 3.2 cm2) using a band-saw and decontaminated mechanically to minimize contamination using ultraclean procedures (Ro and others, Reference Ro2020). All sample preparations were performed under a class 10 vertical laminar flow clean bench in a cold room at −15°C. Each core stick was secured in a pre-cleaned cylindric Teflon tumbler (5 cm in diameter) with pre-cleaned Teflon screws. The core section was then decontaminated by chiseling three successive layers (∼2 mm each) from the outside toward the center of the stick using pre-cleaned ceramic knives (Models: FK075WH, Kyocera Advanced Ceramics, Kyoto, Japan). The uncontaminated inner part of the stick was cut at an average depth interval of 5.5 cm. Each cut subsample was discretely collected in pre-cleaned 1 L wide-mouth low-density polyethylene (LDPE) bottles (Nalgene, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Wiesbaden, Germany) and kept frozen until analysis. A total of 164 subsamples were obtained after all the decontamination procedures.
For the depth interval between 12.2 m and 98.5 m (d > ∼ 0.55 g cm–3), processing of the core sections was undertaken using a continuous melting system (see next section). The core sections were cut into 14 cm to 74 cm long sticks according to the given size of each core section, and the ends and breaks of each stick were scraped (∼6 mm in depths between 12.2 and 50.9 m with d values of ∼0.55 to ∼0.80 g cm–3 and ∼2 mm in depths from 50.9 to 98.5 m with d values > ∼0.80 g cm–3) using pre-cleaned ceramic knives before melting to reduce contamination.
2.2.2. Continuous ice core melting system
A continuous ice core melting system installed inside a class 100 laminar flow clean booth in a clean room (class 1000) at KOPRI was used for real-time measurements of the liquid conductivity and insoluble particle counts and for collecting discrete samples from the inner part of the decontaminated ice core sticks between 12.2 and 50.9 m depth. This system was equipped with a pure nickel melting head with drain channels designed to minimize the percolation effects within the firn matrix, along with a conductivity meter (829 Micro Flow Cell S/S*, Amber Science Inc., Eugene, OR, USA), a laser particle counter (Abakus, Klotz, Unterhaugstett, Germany), a flow meter (SLI-2000, Sensirion, Zurich, Switzerland), and an online multi-IC system (see section 2.2.3) (Ro and others, Reference Ro2020). Briefly, with an average melting rate of approximately 1.3 cm min–1, meltwater from the inner section of the melting head was passed through a glass debubbler to remove air bubbles and then through a three-way valve to distribute the stream to the multi-IC and continuous flow analysis (CFA) systems including an online laser particle counter and conductivity meter. The remaining sample stream from the debubbler was manually collected in pre-cleaned 20 mL wide-mouth Nalgene LDPE bottles using a fraction collector, with an average resolution of 6.2 cm per sample. 630 meltwater samples were collected and frozen immediately. Ro and others (Reference Ro2020) provided a detailed description of the analytical procedures.
For ice core sections between a 50.9 and 98.5 m depth, the melting system was slightly modified by replacing the firn melter with one designed for melting high-density ice sections and separating the online multi-IC system (Figure S1). The average melting rate was 0.9 cm min–1, and 1755 melted samples were collected at an average 2.9 cm depth interval.
The total particle concentrations were measured continuously using a laser particle counter with 32 size channels for diameters ranging from 0.8 µm to 100.0 µm and calculated using the directly analyzed flow rates from the flow meter. Although this measurement was not calibrated using the Coulter Counter data from discrete samples (Ruth and others, Reference Ruth, Wagenbach, Steffensen and Bigler2003), the trend of the particle concentration measured from the laser particle counter showed good agreement with that measured using the Coulter Counter (Ruth and others, Reference Ruth2008). The conductivity data were calibrated using a diluted stock standard solution (CAS No.51302153, Mettler Toledo, Columbia, MD, USA). For the top 12.2 m of the core, the particle concentrations and conductivity were measured on discrete samples collected from decontaminated core sticks, as mentioned before. Despite the different sample resolutions, no noticeable gaps were observed between the values in a discrete data series and those from continuous measurements (Figure S2).
2.2.3. Ion chromatography system
The subsamples obtained from the top 12.2 m and the 50.9 m to 98.5 m depth interval were melted at room temperature in a class 10 laminar flow clean bench located in a cleanroom of class 1000. These samples were aliquoted and analyzed for major ionic species (Na+, Ca2+, and SO42–) using Dionex (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Sunnyvale, CA, USA) ICS-2100 and ICS-5000 with an IonPac CS12A (2 × 250 mm) analytical column, methanesulfonic acid eluent, and a CSRS-300 suppressor for Na+ and Ca2+ and Dionex ICS-2000 and ICS-5000 equipped with an IonPac AS15 (2 × 250 mm) analytical column, potassium hydroxide eluent, and an ASRS-300 suppressor for SO42–. The method detection limits, defined as three times the standard deviation (3σ) of 10 measurements of standard solutions (0.4, 1, and 5 μg L–1), were 1.2, 0.46, and 0.58 μg L–1 for Na+, Ca2+, and SO42–, respectively.
The major ions in meltwater from a 12.2 m to 50.9 m depth were analyzed using the online multi-IC system (see section 2.2.2), comprising six Dionex IC sets, ICS-5000 and two ICS-1100s installed with an IonPac CS12A (3 × 150 mm) analytical column, methanesulfonic acid eluent, and a CERS-500 suppressor for Na+ and Ca2+ and ICS-5000, ICS-2100, and ICS-2000 installed with an IonPac AS15 (3 × 150 mm) analytical column, potassium hydroxide eluent and an AERS-500 suppressor for SO42–. The method detection limits (3σ of 10 measurements of 0.2, 0.5 and 25 μg L–1 standard solution) were 0.08, 0.06 and 3.0 μg L–1 for Na+, Ca2, and SO42–, respectively, with a mean sample resolution of 1.8 cm.
The ion concentrations were calibrated using diluted standard solutions from Dionex (Cat No. P/N 046070 for Na+ and Ca2+ and P/N 057590 for SO42−). Data validation was carried out using the calibration parameters and ionic balances to ensure the accuracy and quality of data. Data suspected of being contaminated were excluded after the measurement was completed. The analytical precision was 4.9% for Na+, 6.3% for Ca2+ and 5.6% for SO42−. Further details on these analytical methods are provided elsewhere (Hong and others, Reference Hong2012, Reference Hong2015; Ro and others, Reference Ro2020, Reference Ro2022). Table S1 of the supplementary material lists all ion data.
In this study, non-sea salt (nss–) fractions of Ca2+ and SO42− were calculated using the following equations (Delmas, Reference Delmas1992):


where [Ca2+]sample, [Na+]sample and [SO42–]sample are the measured concentrations of total Ca2+, Na+ and SO42–, respectively, in the samples. [Ca2+/Na+]seawater and [SO42–/Na+]seawater are the ratios of Ca2+/Na+ (0.038 w/w) and SO42–/Na+ (0.25 w/w) in bulk seawater (Kester and others, Reference Kester, Euedall, Connors and Pytkowicz1967). Note that Na+ can originate from both sea salt and continental dust, and therefore, some studies first estimate the sea-salt-derived Na+ budget before calculating the nss-fractions of other ions (e.g., Bigler and others, Reference Bigler, Rothlisberger, Lambert, Stocker and Wagenbach2006). However, it is widely accepted that Na+ in Antarctic aerosols, snow, and ice is predominantly of marine origin, with negligible contribution from dust-derived leachable Na+, particularly during interglacial periods. For example, the nss-fraction of total Na+ at Dome C during the Holocene was estimated to be only around 2% (Röthlisberger and others, Reference Röthlisberger2002). Therefore, Na+ concentrations can reasonably be interpreted as a proxy for sea salt input in this study.
2.2.4. Isotope measurements (δ18O)
For δ18O analysis, ice core samples were first cut into segments (2.3 cm width and 1.5 cm thick) parallel to the core axis and subsampled at an average resolution of 2.3 cm using a band saw. The subsamples were melted at room temperature and filtered through 0.45 µm polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) syringe filters from Merck Millipore (USA). The filtrate was then placed in 2 mL glass vials and analyzed for δ18O using three CRDSs (L1102-i, L2130-i, and L2140-i, Picarro, Santa Clara, CA, USA). All measurements were calibrated using the certified International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) standards of Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water 2 (VSMOW2), Greenland Ice Sheet Precipitation (GISP), and Standard Light Antarctic Precipitation 2 (SLAP2). The analytical precision was 0.06‰. Further details on this analytical method are provided elsewhere (Kim and others, Reference Kim, Han, Hur, Yoshimura and Lee2019, Reference Kim, Han, Moon, Han, Hur and Lee2022).
2.3. Calculation of snow accumulation rate
Based on the established ice chronology, the annual SAR at the SGP was calculated in millimeters of water equivalent per year (mm w.e. yr–1) using the density of the core sections evaluated by weighing each section directly in the field (see section 2.1) and a correction for the layer thickness. This correction was accomplished using thinning functions representing the reduced thickness (λ) to the initial thickness (λH) ratio of an annual layer. The SGP was characterized by low horizontal ice flow velocities (0.9–2.3 m yr−1) (Yang and others, Reference Yang2018; Kim and others, Reference Kim, Prior, Han, Qi, Han and Ju2020). Kim and others (Reference Kim, Prior, Han, Qi, Han and Ju2020) also reported that the depth interval analyzed in this study was affected by a simple vertical strain, whereas the strain regime became complex below ∼ 110 m due to the bedrock topography near a nunatak located ∼ 4 km southeast of the Styx-M core site. Accordingly, the effects of the vertical strain-induced layer thinning were accounted for using linear least squares fitting models developed by Nye (Reference Nye1963) (Nye model) and Dansgarrd and Johnsen (Reference Dansgarrd and Johnsen1969) (D–J model). The Nye model assumes a constant vertical strain rate throughout the entire depth of the ice sheet, while the D–J model assumes a constant vertical strain rate from the surface to a certain depth (kink height, h) and a linear decrease in vertical strain below this depth to zero at the base of the ice sheet (H). The thinning function used for the SAR calculation was derived by averaging six thinning scenarios, incorporating the Nye model and D–J model with five different h (100, 200, 300, 400, and 500 m), consistent with the parameters used by Yang and others (Reference Yang2018). The uncertainty of the thinning function was assumed to increase linearly with depth at a rate of 0.06% m–1 (1σ of the thinning functions calculated from the six scenarios divided by the corresponding depth). Additional uncertainty associated with the assumption of simple vertical strain at the SGP cannot be excluded. Despite these uncertainties, the thinning functions for depths between 68.1 m and 98.2 m showed good agreement with those derived from gas-based ice ages and their corresponding depths, which were also influenced by the thinning effects (Figure S3), suggesting that the layer thinning corrections had been properly performed.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Ice core chronology (1259–2014 CE)
Manual layer counting was extended to a depth of 98.5 m using the previous approach building upon the previously established chronology for the top 9.89 m (1979–2014 CE), determined through annual layer counting based on the seasonally varying profiles of δ18O, nssSO42–, and nssSO42–/Na+ with summer maxima and Na+ and liquid conductivity with winter/spring maxima (Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel, Han, Kim, Hong, Lee and Hur2020, Reference Nyamgerel2024; Ro and others, Reference Ro2020, Reference Ro2022). A key methodological difference in this study compared to previous studies is the exclusion of δ18O as a seasonal marker, due to the significant signal smoothing below 9.89 m likely caused by post-depositional alteration and molecular diffusion in the firn (Johnsen and others, Reference Johnsen, Clausen, Cuffey, Hoffmann, Schwander and Creyts2000; see Figures 2 and S4). Figures 2 and S4 show the manual identification of annual layers based on the nssSO42–, nssSO42–/Na+, Na+, and liquid conductivity profiles. These impurity records exhibited apparent seasonal variations, as shown in Figure 3. Although the sampling resolution was sufficiently high in the upper 50.9 m (∼8 samples per year) to capture seasonal signals in the ion records, the interval below this depth had a lower sampling resolution (∼4 samples per year). Considering the effects of ice-thinning at greater depths, the ionic profiles may exhibit seasonal bias, particularly toward seasons with higher snow accumulation. Despite this, the impurity records exhibited well-defined seasonal patterns, highlighting their reliability as seasonality indicators across the core section (see Figures 2 and 3).

Figure 2. Profiles of δ18O, nssSO42–, nssSO42–/Na+, Na+, liquid conductivity, dust number concentrations (uncalibrated), and nssCa2+ at the depth intervals of (a) 2–7 m (from Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel2024), (b) 17–22 m, and (c) 54–58 m of the Styx-M core. For the full depth profiles, see Figure S4. Horizontal dotted grey lines represent the mid-summer (1 January) of each year, which was assigned based on the ion data points. Horizontal dashed blue line in (b) represents an uncertain layer having potentials but not assigned as an annual layer. Horizontal dashed red lines represent the depth intervals showing the anomalous peaks in nssSO42– coinciding with high concentrations of Na+ (see section 3.1).

Figure 3. Seasonal (summer, December–February; autumn, March–May; winter, June–August; and spring, September–November) mean values of the chemical impurities used for counting annual layers in the Styx-M core records. Annual signals in the impurity records are used to calculate a three-month seasonal mean after interpolating values at monthly intervals over a one-year period. The ion records from the depth intervals exhibiting anomalous, simultaneous peaks in Na+ and nssSO42– concentrations were excluded
During layer counting, challenges were encountered at specific depth intervals, where multiple nssSO42− peaks appeared within a single year (e.g., around 17.4, 18.2, and 21.8 m; see Figure 2b). This may result from sporadic biogenic sulfur inclusions from the adjacent oceans (Goursaud and others, Reference Goursaud2017; Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021; Emanuelsson and others, Reference Emanuelsson, Thomas, Tetzner, Humby and Vladimirova2022; Hoffmann and others, Reference Hoffmann2022). In such cases, summer layers were determined based on troughs in winter markers or subjectively decided when seasonal signals were ambiguous to optimize consistency with absolute age markers (see below). In addition, nssSO42− concentrations typically exhibited depleted to negative values during colder seasons (see Figure 2), likely due to sulfate depletion in sea salt aerosols from the sea ice surface, caused by mirabilite precipitation (Na2SO4 · 10H2O) (Wagenbach and others, Reference Wagenbach1998; Legrand and others, Reference Legrand, Preunkert, Wolff, Weller, Jourdain and Wagenbach2017). On the other hand, sporadic nssSO42− peaks were observed within one to two data points, accompanied by abnormally high Na+ concentrations (often exceeding 1 mg L–1), which are likely linked to storm events originating from the Ross Sea (Ro and others, Reference Ro2022). These anomalies did not correspond to known volcanic events and were found alongside the troughs in the δ18O and nssSO42–/Na+ profiles, which are indicative of cold seasons (e.g., at a depth of 5.24 m; see Figure 2a). Such spikes have also been recorded in snowpit/firn cores from the Victoria Land glaciers (Gragnani and others, Reference Gragnani, Smiraglia, Stenni and Torcini1998; Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2000; Kwak and others, Reference Kwak2015; Ro and others, Reference Ro2022). Although the intermittent influences of unidentified volcanism in northern Victoria Land cannot be excluded, we propose an alternative explanation for these phenomena based on the typical concurrent spikes in insoluble particles and nssCa2+: an abnormal influx of sulfate-containing particles such as gypsum (CaSO4 · 2H2O), calcium carbonate (CaCO3) reacted with atmospheric H2SO4, or H2SO4 hydrates. Gypsum and carbonate minerals can be supplied from local rock outcrops in the TAM (Iizuka and others, Reference Iizuka2013) and deposited anomalously at the SGP under strong wind conditions. H2SO4 hydrates formed in polar stratospheric clouds during the colder seasons could be transported downslope via katabatic flows (Carslaw and others, Reference Carslaw1998; Watanabe and others, Reference Watanabe, Sato and Takahashi2006), consistent with the geographical features of the SGP located downhill from the TAM (see section 2.1). However, a detailed investigation of these processes is beyond the scope of this study. Therefore, nssSO42− peaks coinciding with Na+, nssCa2+, and insoluble particle spikes were attributed to the colder seasons (highlighted by dashed red lines in Figures 2 and S4 and blue stars in Figure 4).

Figure 4. Profiles of nssSO42– concentration (black) and 239Pu concentration (green; Shin and others, Reference Shin, Lee, Han, Hwang, Ro and Hur2025) at the top 98.5 m of the Styx-M core. Temporal horizons include known (red numbers and letters) and unknown (red stars) major volcanic signals and Rittmann tephra layer (brown; Lee and others, Reference Lee, Kyle, Iverson, Lee and Han2019) (see Table 1). Red numbers (#1–5) indicate known volcanic events used as age-depth tie points (see text), and their dates are listed in the box below the figure. Red letters denote known eruptions whose timing is inferred exclusively from chronological considerations and thus are not utilized as tie points (a: 1955 CE Carrán-Los Venados, b: 1886 CE Tarawera, c: 1846 CE Armagura, d: 1835 CE Cosiguina, e: 1822 CE Gallungung, f: 1673 CE Gamkonora, g: 1640 CE Parker Peak). RMN and SD are the running mean and standard deviation, respectively, of nssSO42– biogenic background levels after removing values greater than the 95% percentile in the total nssSO42– concentrations. Blue stars represent the depth intervals showing the anomalous peaks in nssSO42– coinciding with high concentrations of Na+ (see section 3.1). The signals of the Pinatubo (N1) and El Chichón (N2) eruptions were already identified in the Styx-M core by Nyamgerel and others (Reference Nyamgerel2024).
Table 1. Age-depth tie points assigned to constrain the styx-m core chronology

a Numbers of each volcanic event marked in Figure 4.
b V: Volcanic eruption; N.T.: Nuclear test.
c Annual-layer dating using the StratiCounter layer-counting algorithm (Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup, Svensson, Rasmussen, Winther, Steig and Axelrod2012).
d From Nyamgerel and others (Reference Nyamgerel2024).
e From Shin and others (Reference Shin, Lee, Han, Hwang, Ro and Hur2025).
f From Lee and others (Reference Lee, Kyle, Iverson, Lee and Han2019).
The layer counting result was further refined using age-depth tie-points such as atmospheric nuclear tests indicated by the 239Pu record (Shin and others, Reference Shin, Lee, Han, Hwang, Ro and Hur2025) and major volcanic eruptions identified in the nssSO42− record based on the following criteria (Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2020, Reference Nardin2021): (1) at least one nssSO42− sample exceeding the running mean (RMN) plus three times the standard deviation (RMN + 3σ) of the biogenic nssSO42− background data (produced by excluding the top 5% of total nssSO42− concentrations) and (2) at least two consecutive data points above the RMN + 2σ (Figure 4). Previous studies identified two 239Pu peaks at 12.7 m and 14.3 m, corresponding to the nuclear tests conducted by the USSR in 1961–62 CE and the USA in 1952–54 CE, respectively (Hwang and others, Reference Hwang, Hur, Lee, Han, Hong and Motoyama2019; Shin and others, Reference Shin, Lee, Han, Hwang, Ro and Hur2025). These peaks were assigned to 1965 CE and 1955 CE, respectively (Table 1), considering the delayed fallout deposition caused by long-range transport and the assigned years of volcanic eruptions recorded near these 239Pu peaks (see below). In addition, 12 volcanic eruptions were identified in this study, along with the previously reported Pinatubo and El Chichón eruptions at depths of 5.71–6.59 m and 8.20 m, respectively (Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel2024) (Figure 4). Although the nssSO42− signal for the Agung eruption did not meet the volcanic identification criteria, it matched the annual layer counting and the 239Pu-derived date at 12.7 m, supporting the rigor of these criteria. We note here that although all volcanic events identified in this study have been previously reported, several volcanic signals are difficult to definitely link to specific events. As shown in Table S2, Antarctic ice cores commonly contain records of the well-known 1963 CE Agung, 1815 CE Tambora, 1809 CE unknown, 1600 CE Huaynaputina, 1458 CE unknown (likely from Kuwae), and 1257 CE Samalas eruptions, whereas several eruptions (e.g., 1955 CE Carrán-Los Venados, 1846 CE Armagura, and 1822 CE Gallunggung eruptions) have been detected in a limited number of ice cores. Interestingly, the 1809 and 1458 CE eruption signals were not detected in our records. The absence of signals is most likely due to high biogenic sulfur backgrounds at coastal sites or the uncertainty of the expected depth intervals (39.9‒40.2 m and 80.0‒80.7 m) where no data are available (see Table S1 and Figure S4). To ensure robust age-depth tie points, we only used the 1963 CE Agung, 1815 CE Tambora, 1600 CE Huaynaputina, and 1257 CE Samalas eruption signals (Table 1 and Figure 4). Based on these absolute age tie points, the Styx-M core chronology was estimated to cover the last 755 years (1259–2014 CE).
The constrained manual layer counting result was compared with ice chronologies produced by the automated StratiCounter algorithm (Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup, Svensson, Rasmussen, Winther, Steig and Axelrod2012) and a fifth-degree polynomial age-dating model to verify the robustness of the established chronology. The polynomial model was extrapolated based on fixed points, including the surface age (2015 CE), identified age-depth tie-points, Rittmann tephra layer, and gas chronology of the Styx-M core. The Rittmann tephra, a widely distributed 1252 ± 2 CE tephra layer in Antarctic ice, was identified at a 99.2 m depth (Lee and others, Reference Lee, Kyle, Iverson, Lee and Han2019) and was assigned to 1252 CE in this study (Table 1). Gas ages from 177 points between 68.1 m and 169.8 m, determined by Yang and others (Reference Yang2018), were converted to ice ages by subtracting the ice–gas age difference (Δage) of 320 years, estimated at the depth of the Rittmann tephra layer. The Δage was assumed to be constant with time, with an uncertainty of 20 years (Yang and others, Reference Yang2018). The fifth-degree polynomial was selected because it best matched the known age of the fixed points. Consequently, the manual layer counting-derived chronology agreed well with the age-dating results from the automated and model-based approaches (Figure 5), reinforcing the robustness of the established ice chronology.

Figure 5. The Styx-M core chronologies based on annual layer counting in the depth interval between 9.89 and 98.5 m established in this study (red line) and for the top 9.89 m by Nyamgerel and others (Reference Nyamgerel2024) (light blue line), as well as the StratiCounter program (blue line) and the fifth-degree polynomial age model (black line) (see text). More details on the statistic information applied in the StratiCounter program are given elsewhere (Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup, Svensson, Rasmussen, Winther, Steig and Axelrod2012). Also shown are the depth intervals of 239Pu peaks (green squares; Shin and others., Reference Shin, Lee, Han, Hwang, Ro and Hur2025), well-defined signals from major volcanic eruptions (dark blown circles), Rittmann tephra layer (gold diamond; Lee and others, Reference Lee, Kyle, Iverson, Lee and Han2019), and methane tie-points (purple triangles; Yang and others, Reference Yang2018) (see Table 1 and Figure 4). the methane tie-points below 98.5 m are not shown.
The uncertainty of the annual layer counting was estimated by summing individual layer uncertainties, each assigned as 0.5 ± 0.5 years (Rasmussen and others, Reference Rasmussen2006; Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021), between consecutive tie-points. Layer uncertainties were based on ambiguous layers (i.e., layers with seasonal signals but not confidently assigned as annual) and assigned layers within depth intervals of missing records of impurities, corresponding to the scraped sections of the core during decontamination or samples for which the measurement results could not be obtained because of analytical issues (see section 2.2 and Figure S4). The number of years assigned within these missing sections was estimated using the average ratio between the number of years and the associated depth intervals before and after each gap (Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021). Table 2 lists calculated age uncertainties, ranging from 1.5 to 16 years (2.2 to 4.4%) for the respective depth intervals. Furthermore, comparisons of the assigned years of the age–depth tie-points (except CH4 tie-points) with those from the automated layer counting and the polynomial model revealed differences of ± 1 year and − 8 to 4 years, respectively (Table 1). The CH4 tie-points were excluded from the comparison because Δage, which was assumed to be constant in this study, actually fluctuates with time (Blunier and others, Reference Blunier, Spahni, Barnola, Chappallaz, Loulergue and Schwander2007; Jang and others, Reference Jang2019), likely introducing potential uncertainties in the gas-derived ice ages, as shown by the slight distortions in age between 87.4 m and 97.9 m (see Figure 5). Considering all factors, the maximum dating uncertainty was estimated to be ± 8 years.
Table 2. Uncertainties in annual layer counting for the depth intervals between two consecutive tie-points from the styx-m core (also see Table 1). uncertainties have not been quantified when the impurity records show clear annual cycles between consecutive tie points. No uncertainties exist for dating the top 9.89 m (Nyamgerel and others, Reference Nyamgerel2024)

3.2. Temporal snow accumulation variability
Based on the dating achieved, the mean annual SAR between 1259 CE and 2014 CE was calculated using the methodology described in section 2.3. Table S3 lists the calculated annual SARs. The annual SAR during this period was averaged at 113 ± 39 (1σ) mm w.e. yr–1 (Table S4), which was slightly lower than a firn densification model-based estimate of 130 mm w.e. yr–1 (Han and others, Reference Han2015). However, this model-based SAR estimation may include uncertainty, primarily due to its assumption of a constant SAR throughout the simulation period (Han and others, Reference Han2015).
The robustness of the observed results was evaluated by comparing the present data-driven annual SAR record with the annual mean precipitation–minus–evaporation (P–E) budget at the grid point (163.75°E and 73.75°S) nearest to the SGP, calculated using the ERA5 reanalysis from the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) for the period between 1940 and 2014 CE (Hersbach and others, Reference Hersbach2020) (Figure S5). The mean SARs derived from the Styx-M core and ERA5 reanalysis were comparable during the corresponding period, with mean values of 117 ± 41 and 109 ± 26 mm w.e. yr–1, respectively (Table S4). Compared to the less variable temporal fluctuations in the ERA5 P–E budget, however, the Styx-M core SAR record exhibited enhanced values from the mid-1970s to the mid-1980s and during the 1990s (Figure S5). This suggests that the ERA5 model may not properly capture the orographic effects on small-scale SAR patterns in mountainous regions (Daloz and others, Reference Daloz2020; Blau and others, Reference Blau, Kad, Turton and Ha2024). Nevertheless, no significant differences in the overall temporal trends between the different datasets reflect the confidence in the reliability of these results, validating its utility for reconstructing the temporal patterns of the centennial-scale SAR changes at the SGP.
Figure 6a shows the full ice core record of annual SAR and its variability over the past 755 years, from 1259 CE to 2014 CE. Considering the maximum absolute uncertainty (± 8 years) in the depth-age scale, an eight-year running-averaged SAR record was used to examine the temporal SAR variability at the SGP. The temporal variability of the record highlights the dominance of negative SAR anomalies, defined as values lower than the average over the entire period of record, lasting from the mid-13th century to the end of the 16th century. Since ∼ 1600 CE, above-average snow accumulation values were observed, with intermittent negative anomalies, particularly during the 18th century. Despite the existence of inter-decadal and multi-decadal fluctuations, this record revealed a statistically significant increase (∼30%; p < 0.001) in the mean SARs throughout the entire period of 755 years (Figure 6a), with an increase in the average SAR values from 86 ± 29 mm w.e. yr−1 at the beginning of the record (1259‒1300 CE) to 122 ± 32 mm w.e. yr−1 in recent years (2000‒2014 CE) (Table S4). The long-term increasing trend was partly consistent with the ice flow thinning model-based SAR record reconstructed from the Styx-M core, showing a continuous increase of the SAR at the depth from 98.5 (1259 CE) to ∼ 40 m (∼1813 CE) (Yang and others, Reference Yang2018). On the other hand, in contrast to a clear positive trend of the annual SAR over the past two centuries in this record (Figure 6a), the model-based SAR time series revealed a significant decrease in the SAR during the same period (Yang and others, Reference Yang2018). This apparent discrepancy between the two SAR records is probably because Yang and others (Reference Yang2018) calculated the annual SAR with the ice age-depth model based on a linear interpolation of the gas-derived chronology that was determined by matching the CH4 age tie-points at the 85.7 to 167.1 m depth interval with the gas chronology of the WAIS Divide ice core (WD2014 scale) (Buizert and others, Reference Buizert2015). Such interpolation could introduce significant errors in reconstructing the SAR record from the upper part of the core because the gas-derived SAR estimation does not resolve the high-frequency variations (Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019). This emphasizes the importance of achieving well-constrained chronologies of ice cores using a multiple-proxy approach for reconstructing the long-term variations in snow accumulation at a given site.

Figure 6. Time series of the annual (thin line) and 8-yr running averaged (thick line) snow accumulation rates from (a) the Styx-M (1259‒2014 CE; this study), (b) GV7 (1179‒2009 CE; Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021), (c) Talos Dome (1217‒1996 CE; Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2002), (d) Hercules Névé (1770‒1992 CE; Stenni and others, Reference Stenni1999), and (e) Roosevelt Island Climate Evolution (RICE) (700 BCE‒2012 CE; Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019) ice cores. Color shadings represent above- (red) and below-average (blue) accumulation rates, respectively. Also shown are the linear regression lines over the entire period (dotted green in a–e) and the period between 1725 and 2014 CE (dotted yellow in a–b).
The overall increasing trend in the Styx-M SAR record for the last 755 years was generally in agreement with the 800-year SAR variability record from the GV7 ice core, recovered from the coast of Oates Land (Figure 1), which showed a consistent increase in the accumulation rate during the corresponding period (Figure 6b) (Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021). Nevertheless, a different spatial pattern was observed in the trend of the SAR variability in Victoria Land for the Talos Dome (TD) ice core record (Figures 1 and 6c), providing the long-term SAR variability back to ∼ 800 years (Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2002). A long-term accumulation record from this core showed no consistent increase in the SAR over time (Figure 6c). On decadal to centennial timescales over the last 300 years, our SAR variability record exhibited decadal-scale fluctuations with the dominance of above-average accumulation values after the early 1800s and a long-lasting centennial scale increase in the period between 1725 to 2014 CE (Figure 6a). This feature was observed in the SAR variability record from the GV7 core (Nardin and others, Reference Nardin2021). For comparison, the SAR variability record from the Hercules Névé firn core, northern Victoria (Figure 1), spanning at least 200 years, showed mean accumulation rates greater than the average after the mid-19th century (Figure 6d) (Stenni and others, Reference Stenni1999). In contrast, the TD core record was characterized by SAR values larger than the long-term average value during the 20th century (Figure 6c) (Stenni and others, Reference Stenni2002). Compared to the SAR variability elsewhere in the western Ross Sea region, the accumulation rate record of the Roosevelt Island Climate Evolution (RICE) ice core from the eastern Ross Sea (Figure 1), covering the past 2700 years, showed a clear long-term decreasing trend from the mid-13th century to the present with the dominance of below-average accumulation values after the early 1700s (Figure 6e) (Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019). This contradictory feature exhibited a distinct dipole pattern of opposed accumulation variability between the eastern and western Ross Sea region, referred to as the Ross Sea Dipole, which can be attributed to the complex interaction effects of the oceanic and atmospheric impact factors (Scarchilli and others, Reference Scarchilli, Frezzotti and Ruti2011; Bertler and others, Reference Bertler2018; Emanuelsson and others, Reference Emanuelsson2018; Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019).
Overall, the observed differences between the spatial and temporal variations in the SARs core records accentuate the importance of reconstructing long-term snow accumulation patterns from the coast to the interior across the Ross Sea region. Snow accumulation in the Ross Sea region may be related to large-scale atmospheric dynamics such as those induced by the El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and the Southern Annular Mode (SAM) as well as synoptic-scale cyclones that can have significant impacts on the extent of sea ice (Markle and others, Reference Markle, Bertler, Sinclair and Sneed2012; Bertler and others, Reference Bertler2018; Emanuelsson and others, Reference Emanuelsson2018; Winstrup and others, Reference Winstrup2019). Future studies will be needed to investigate the dominant factors controlling the decadal- to centennial-variability of snow accumulation and unravel the detailed links of the SAR variability with those for the various components of the ocean, atmosphere, and climate preserved in the Styx-M core.
4. Conclusion
We have here presented a chronology for the upper 98.5 m of the 210.5 m deep Styx-M ice core drilled at the Styx Glacier plateau in northern Victoria Land, East Antarctica. The dating of the ice core is based on the annual layer counting of seasonal variations in the nssSO42–, nssSO42–/Na+, Na+, and meltwater conductivity signals. The annual layer counting was further constrained with a series of absolute age markers, including the 239Pu peaks (1955 and 1965 CE) produced by atmospheric nuclear tests and 12 large volcanic eruptions in recorded history identified from the prominent nssSO42− peaks. The chronology for the upper 98.5 m of the Styx-M core covered 755 years from 1259 to 2014 CE with a maximum absolute uncertainty of ± 8 years at the bottom of the core analyzed. The annual SARs were calculated using the established depth-age chronology and density of the core as a function of depth, providing an average of 113 ± 39 (1σ) mm w.e. yr–1 over the entire period. Despite the inter-decadal and multi-decadal fluctuations, a ∼ 30% increase in the mean SARs from the beginning of the record to the present day was observed. The SAR records revealed the dominance of the below-average accumulation values from the mid-13th century to the end of the 16th century and above-average values after the early 1800s, with a long-lasting increase on the centennial scale since the early 18th century between 1725 and 2014 CE. The different temporal patterns of the SAR variability were observed between the ice core records from the SGP and different areas in the Ross Sea Region. In particular, the distinct dipole pattern of opposed accumulation variability between the eastern and western Ross Sea region indicates the complex interaction effects of the oceanic and atmospheric impact factors influencing the snow accumulation patterns across the Ross Sea region. Further research combining multiple proxy records in the Styx-M core will provide valuable insights into the intricate mechanisms affecting the pattern of snowfall amounts that vary spatially and temporally in the Ross Sea region. This will help gain a better understanding of the past and predict the changes in the mass balance of Victoria Land in response to climate change.
Supplementary material
The supplementary material for this article can be found at https://doi.org/10.1017/jog.2025.10074.
Data availability
Ion data (Na+, Ca2+, and SO42− ) and reconstructed SAR data used in this study can be obtained from the supplementary material. Particle number concentrations and meltwater conductivity data will be published in future research.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to summer season researchers participating in field activities at the SGP in December 2014 to January 2015 and to KOPRI technicians and engineers for preparing and measuring the Styx-M core samples. A special acknowledgement is given to the late Morihiro Miyahara, who participated in this program with great enthusiasm. Without his dedication and guidance for teaching us ice core drilling techniques, this work could not have been accomplished successfully. The authors also thank the ECMWF for providing the ERA5 reanalysis dataset. This research was supported by a research grant (PE25100) from KOPRI and by the Basic Science Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (NRF-2018R1A2B2006489).
Author contributions
Sang-Bum Hong and Sungmin Hong designed the project. All of the authors contributed to decontamination, measurement, and dating of the Styx-M core. The original manuscript was written by Seokhyun Ro, with significant contributions of Yeongcheol Han, Sang-Bum Hong, and Sungmin Hong to manuscript revision. All of the authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.